Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Lifestyle
Kaleigh Werner

Monsters: Lyle and Erik Menendez: How the cast compares to their real-life counterparts

Getty/Netflix

Your support helps us to tell the story

My recent work focusing on Latino voters in Arizona has shown me how crucial independent journalism is in giving voice to underrepresented communities.

Your support is what allows us to tell these stories, bringing attention to the issues that are often overlooked. Without your contributions, these voices might not be heard.

Every dollar you give helps us continue to shine a light on these critical issues in the run up to the election and beyond

Eric Garcia

Eric Garcia

Washington Bureau Chief

28 years after Lyle and Erik Menéndez were sentenced to life in prison for murdering their parents, Kitty and José, Netflix is revisiting their case with the new drama Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story.

From the mind of Ryan Murphy, the new Netflix series will take viewers through the notorious American murders with a star-studded cast including Chloe Sevigny, Javier Bardem, Ari Graynor, Dallas Roberts, and Nathan Lane. Lyle will be played by Hollywood newcomer Nicolas Alexander Chavez, while Cooper Koch will take on the role of Erik.

Sevigny and Bardem play the role of Kitty and José, respectively.

The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story is the second instalment in Murphy’s controversial Monsters saga. In 2022, he revisited the exploits of the “Milwaukee Cannibal” in Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story. The series was a tremendous hit, reaching 1 billion hours of views in its first 60 days and prompting widespread debate about the glamorisation of murderers.

In the new drama, Murphy will widen the scope of the case to include the harrowing sexual abuse Lyle and Erik alleged to have been perpetrated by their father.

Lyle and Erik were arrested for first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder outside their home in March of 1990. They were then sentenced to life in prison in 1996. In 2024, new evidence has the potential to set them free.

With the release of the fresh true crime rendition, here is a run-through of all the cast members and how they compare to their real-life counterparts.

Nicolas Alexander Chavez as Lyle Menéndez

Lyle Menéndez (left) and Nicolas Alexander Chavez (right)
Lyle Menéndez (left) and Nicolas Alexander Chavez (right) (Getty/Netflix)

Chavez, 25, will be assuming the role of Lyle, the older Menéndez brother and a former Princeton University student. Lyle was suspended from Princeton for an entire year after he was accused of plagiarizing. After his parents’ murders, he spent $300,000 on a down payment for a chicken wing restaurant called Chuck’s Spring Street Cafe.

Viewers may recognize Chavez from General Hospital and Crushed.

Cooper Koch as Erik Menéndez

Erik Menéndez (left) and Cooper Koch (right) playing Erik
Erik Menéndez (left) and Cooper Koch (right) playing Erik (Getty/Netflix)

The younger Menéndez brother will be played by Koch, the 28-year-old star from Less Than Zero, They/Them, Swallowed, and A New York Christmas Wedding. Erik Menéndez was bound for the University of California Los Angeles before he was arrested for the murder of his parents.

However, before his parents’ death, his father had told him he wasn’t allowed to move in to the dorms. José wanted him to continue living at home and commute to school from Beverly Hills.

Apple TV+ logo

Watch Apple TV+ free for 7 days

New subscribers only. £8.99/mo. after free trial. Plan auto-renews until cancelled

Try for free
Apple TV+ logo

Watch Apple TV+ free for 7 days

New subscribers only. £8.99/mo. after free trial. Plan auto-renews until cancelled

Try for free

Chloe Sevigny as Kitty Menéndez

Kitty Menéndez (left) and Chloe Sevigny (right) in the new Netflix drama
Kitty Menéndez (left) and Chloe Sevigny (right) in the new Netflix drama (Netflix/CBS News)

Sevigny, the 49-year-old actress and model celebrated for her roles in American Psycho and The Act, will play Kitty Menéndez in the Netflix adaptation. Kitty, born Mary Louise Andersen, grew up in Wateseka, Illinois. During the Menéndez trial, Lyle testified that his mother had known about the abuse from his father and that she would also “beat and kick” him. According to crime investigator Rachel Pergament, Kitty’s father Charles abused her and her mother Mae Andersen.

Javier Bardem as José Menéndez

José Menéndez (left) and Javier Bardem (right) as José
José Menéndez (left) and Javier Bardem (right) as José (Netflix/CBS News)

Bardem, who is often known for playing characters with an unhinged verve, will be assuming the role of José Menéndez. The 55-year-old actor has starred in projects including No Country for Old Men, Skyfall, Eat, Pray, Love the new Dune franchise.

José, the patriarch of the Menéndez family, had fled from Cuba to a town in Pennsylvannia when he was a teenager. He attended Southern Illinois University where he met Kitty and lived in New York before eventually settling in Beverly Hills as an entertainment executive. In 1996, Erik said he thought his father was a part of the Mafia.

Ari Graynor as Leslie Abramson

Leslie Abramson (left) and Ari Graynor (right) playing the attorney
Leslie Abramson (left) and Ari Graynor (right) playing the attorney (Getty/Netflix)

Graynor, the star of Bad Teacher and The Sopranos, will play Leslie Abramson, Erik’s defense attorney in both trials. At the time, Abramson was a respected defense attorney in California with a proven track record of persuading juries against the death row penalty. Abramson remained close to Erik and Lyle even after the six-year turn of their two trials,

Dallas Roberts as Jerome Oziel

Jerome Oziel (left) and Dallas Roberts (right) as the psychiatrist
Jerome Oziel (left) and Dallas Roberts (right) as the psychiatrist (Court TV/Netflix)

Roberts, celebrated for his roles in Glass Onion (2022) and The Walking Dead, will be transformed into Dr Jerome Oziel. Oziel was Erik’s psychiatrist. In 1989, Erik confessed to killing his parents during a recorded session with Oziel. The therapist later turned in the tapes as evidence, leading to the brothers’ arrest.

Leslie Grossman as Judalon Smyth

Judalon Smyth (left) and Leslie Grossman (right)
Judalon Smyth (left) and Leslie Grossman (right) (Court TV/Netflix)

American Horror Story regular Grossman is taking on the role of Judalon Smyth, Oziel’s mistress. Smyth was listening behind Oziel’s door when Erik confessed to killing his parents. She was Oziel’s former client who became his secret lover. After the two split up, Smyth told the police Oziel had evidence that proved the two brothers were murderers.

Jason Butler Harner as Les Zoeller

Les Zoeller (left) and Jason Butler Harner (right) as the detective in the Netflix drama
Les Zoeller (left) and Jason Butler Harner (right) as the detective in the Netflix drama (Instagram/Netflix)

Harner, the 53-year-old actor of Ozark and Edge of Everything, will play Beverly Hills detective Les Zoeller. In addition to the Menéndez case, Zoeller worked on the Billionaire Boys Club Ponzi scheme. He passed away in 2021 after working in the BHPD for 30 years.

Nathan Lane as Dominick Dunne

Dominick Dunne (left) and Nathan Lane (right) playing the journalist
Dominick Dunne (left) and Nathan Lane (right) playing the journalist (Getty/Netflix)

Lane, 68, will assume the role of Dominick Dunne, a writer and producer who wrote about the Menéndez trial. Lane is known for his roles in The Gilded Age, Only Murders in the Building, The Good Wife, Modern Family, and The Lion King.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.