Two officers who were accused of using unnecessary deadly force after fatally shooting an armed man in 2018 will keep their jobs after the Chicago Police Board voted to suspend them Thursday.
In an 8-0 vote, the board voted to suspend Officers David Taylor and Larry Lanier for 10 days each, finding them not guilty of firing their weapons without justification in the July 3, 2018, shooting of Terrell Eason.
Former CPD Supt. David Brown had filed administrative charges against the officers on April 6, 2021, recommending they both be fired for violating the department’s rules of conduct when they shot and killed Eason. Brown argued that Eason, 33, didn’t pose an “imminent threat” when officers opened fire.
The video of the shooting shows an officer jumping over a fence into a backyard as Eason picks himself up off the grass with a gun in his right hand and starts to run from the officers before he’s shot.
WARNING: VIDEO CONTAINS GRAPHIC VIOLENCE AND MAY NOT BE APPROPRIATE FOR ALL VIEWERS
Both officers opened fire at the scene in the 4700 block of West Fulton, according to reports released by the Civilian Office of Police Accountability — Officer Taylor fired eight rounds, and his partner, Lanier, fired twice.
According to the written ruling on the decision, the footage shows that Eason did not drop his weapon when he fell in the yard, and his finger was “within the trigger well” and not along the slide.
“As he runs, the gun’s muzzle moves back and forth in the officers’ direction. When he looks in Lanier’s direction, the officers fire,” the ruling states.
John Farrell, a use-of-force expert, told the board during hearings this year that the officers’ use of force “was objectively reasonable,” the ruling states.
“Eason’s actions informed Respondent Taylor’s reasonable perception that Eason, desperate to escape, would use his gun to shoot Taylor, his partner, other officers in the immediate area, or civilians in the neighborhood,” the ruling states.
The board did find Taylor and Lanier guilty of failing to activate their body-worn cameras in a timely manner during the incident.
According to the Chicago police account given the night of the shooting, the two officers responded to a call of a person with a gun about 8 p.m. and saw the man run toward the intersection of Wayman Street and Cicero Avenue. The officers pursued him.
Only Taylor’s body camera was activated, according to the reports, and the audio doesn’t kick in until 17 seconds into the video, after the shooting.
The video shows a breathless officer trying to find an address to relay to the ambulance. Eason appears glassy-eyed and motionless as blood seeps through his white T-shirt and the officers turn him onto his stomach to handcuff him.
The officer asks a colleague: “You shot too, right? He wasn’t putting it down. ... Don’t talk.”
Hours after the shooting, police officials said an “armed confrontation” with Eason led to the shooting. The Old Town resident died of multiple gunshot wounds at Stroger Hospital, according to the Cook County medical examiner’s office.
Eason’s mother filed a wrongful-death lawsuit alleging excessive force and accusing the city of allowing an unconstitutional, unwritten custom that leads to police shootings during foot pursuits.
Contributing: Mitchell Armentrout
