Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine on Remand—Still Struggling with Standing No, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit's initial standing rulings were not faithful applications of Supreme Court precedent. Reason · Sep 17, 2024
Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine On Remand "But the Government switched positions before the Supreme Court." Reason · Sep 17, 2024
Rahimi On Remand "We read the Court's analysis in Rahimi to have modified Bruen in at least one relevant respect." Reason · Sep 13, 2024
Second Amendment Roundup: 8th Circuit Rules in Favor of Pistol Brace Owners ATF shoots the side of a barn, draws a target around the bullet holes, and proclaims “bullseye!” Reason · Aug 26, 2024
Interesting Stay Dispute in Seventh Circuit Minors'-Access-to-Porn Case From Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Rokita, decided Friday by Judges Frank Easterbrook and Amy St. Eve: Indiana seeks a stay of the preliminary injunction that a district court entered preventing the enforcement of Ind. Code § 24-4-23, which requires web sites to limit minors' access to certain sexual materials.… Reason · Aug 21, 2024
The ACLU's Response to My Post on the Fifth Circuit's Smith Ruling—And My Reply to the ACLU A debate on a very important Fourth Amendment ruling. Reason · Aug 16, 2024
The Fifth Circuit Shuts Down Geofence Warrants—And Maybe A Lot More An astonishing ruling, and one that creates splits on two differerent issues. Reason · Aug 13, 2024
Judge Ezra's Worrying Behavior in the Buoy Case Judge Ezra boasted about knowing the judges on the Fifth Circuit, being sworn into the Texas Bar by the Chief Judge's husband, and threatened to have the Deputy Solicitor General's lawyer removed from the courtroom. Reason · Aug 8, 2024
Biskupic Part III Confirms What We Already Knew: Justice Alito Lost Majority Opinions in NetChoice and Trevino. There is little here that can't be gleaned from the docket and the split opinions. Reason · Jul 31, 2024
Texas officials celebrate as court allows floating river barrier to remain at the border Governor Greg Abbott said that justice was done and took a jab at President Joe Biden for attempting to have them removed Latin Times · Jul 31, 2024
Atlas Roofing Shrugged Another Burger Court precedent is about to be “abandoned” or “overruled” like Roe, Lemon, Chevron, Abood, and Bakke. Reason · Jul 22, 2024
District Court Rejects Magistrate Judges' Gag Order on Publishing Name of Retroactively Pseudonymized Litigant "Professor Volokh may not ... publicly disclose Plaintiff's name or personal identifying information in any future writings, speeches, or other public discourse." Reason · Jul 17, 2024
Making Sense of the Moody Opinions In NetChoice I think it is clear that Justice Alito lost the majority, but the resulting schizophrenic opinions still do not cohere. Reason · Jul 15, 2024
Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Amateur sports, geofence warrants, and a Saudi kill squad. Reason · Jul 12, 2024
Fortune · Jul 9, 2024 How an ideological war over PrEP threatens preventive services from smoking cessation to contraception to vaccines for half the U.S. population More than 150 million Americans now have access to preventive services—and these are popular across the political spectrum.
Texas Observer · Jul 8, 2024 Taking Prison to Court: Fighting for the Right to Sleep Michael Garrett sued the Texas Department of Criminal Justice more than a decade ago, and he’s working from inside to keep the case alive.
The Independent UK · Jul 2, 2024 Supreme Court sidesteps gun law challenge that could impact Hunter Biden’s case Supreme Court asked lower appeals courts to remand a case cited by Hunter Biden’s lawyers
Reason · Jul 2, 2024 S. Ct. Will Decide: May States Require Age Verification to Access Porn Sites? The Court just agreed to hear this case, Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton. You can read the majority and dissenting opinions in the Fifth Circuit here, and the petition, response, and reply here. Here's the issue in a nutshell: 1. Ginsberg v. N.Y.(1968) held (in a majority opinion by Justice…
Reason · Jul 1, 2024 Social Media Moderation Is Speech, Says Supreme Court The Court is remanding these two cases for more analysis—but it made its views on some key issues clear.
Reason · Jun 28, 2024 Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Overloaded fireworks, behavioral coaching, and makeshift pockets.
Reason · Jun 28, 2024 Why Does (It At Least Appear That) Justice Barrett Applies "New," "Heightened," and "Elevated" Standing Rules? Justice Barrett adamantly resists the suggestion that she keeps leveling up the burden on plaintiffs, but it is becoming more difficult to deny.
Reason · Jun 27, 2024 The Facial Challenge Analysis In Rahimi Seems Inconsistent with Lopez Why did Lopez, who was paid $40 to bring a gun to a school, succeed on a facial challenge, but the Court wouldn't even consider Rahimi's circumstances?
Reason · Jun 27, 2024 KBJ DGAF Unlike Justices Sotomayor and Kagan, Justice Jackson has no problems criticizing Justice Barrett.
Reason · Jun 26, 2024 The Supreme Court's Dangerous Standing Ruling in Murthy v. Missouri The standing requirements laid down by the majority might make it extremely difficult or impossible for victims of indirect goverment censorship to get their cases to court.