This Christmas season, Amazon Prime has once again come under fire for allegedly trimming down an important scene from an all-time classic holiday movie. Last year, fans who tuned in to watch the beloved 1946 fantasy drama film, It’s a Wonderful Life, were in for a surprise.
One of the most crucial scenes from the third act was missing, drawing backlash, and the controversy has resurfaced this year after viewers came to a similar realization. Three different versions of the film exist in the service’s streaming library, further adding to viewers’ confusion.
“I saw this version! I was so confused,” one user said on X.
Directed by Frank Capra, the movie follows banker George Bailey, played by James Stewart, who attempts to take his own life on Christmas Day, until his guardian angel, Clarence Odbody, intervenes.
Amazon Prime allegedly deleted one of the most pivotal scenes in It’s a Wonderful Life
The movie explores George’s dissatisfaction with his life, having abandoned his personal ambitions to help the community of Bedford Falls. A series of misfortunes causes George to wish he had never been born.
As a result, Clarence takes him through an alternate timeline version of the town, now known as the unsavory “Pottersville.” During his time there, George sees how his absence would negatively impact the community, resulting in a bleak existence for many residents.
The scene marks a turning point in George’s journey as it changes his perspective on life and propels the story to a happy ending. However, the streaming service has allegedly removed the “Pottersville” sequence from the movie, which has earned it the ire of many subscribers.
Viewers first noticed the discrepancies last year during the holiday season and voiced their displeasure. Some sources attributed the cuts to the film’s long and complicated ownership and copyright history.
Viewers slammed Amazon Prime over the trimmed-down version of It’s a Wonderful Life
The controversy resurfaced this year as angry viewers slammed the edited version of It’s a Wonderful Life on X. Many agreed that the omitted scene is crucial to the narrative and dilutes its overall impact.
“Yeah… we watched it last night, unknowingly, they deleted the MOST IMPORTANT part! UGH!” one user commented on X.
A second viewer wrote, “Horrible! That’s the big moment!”
“???? I watched it on Prime last night, and it wasn’t cut out,” a third person commented.
The confusion over the controversially omitted scene most likely stems from the streaming service housing three different versions.
The black & white version has a runtime of 118 minutes, which is less than the movie’s original 130-minute cut. The colored version is the same length as the original, while the “abridged” version is the most heavily trimmed down at only 106 minutes.
The latter also features the most egregious cuts, with viewers noticing that the entire war-affected history of Bedford Falls, George’s car accident, and his desperation on the bridge have been removed.
One Reddit user said of the abridged version, “It sounds like they super sanitized it, removing all the parts that are grim,” criticizing it for removing George’s “rock bottom” moment before everything goes back to normal and he’s overcome with joy.
Netizens encourage physical media ownership following Amazon Prime’s It’s a Wonderful Life controversy
Several netizens who were already aware of the edited versions encouraged others to purchase the movie physically so they could keep revisiting it each year.
“I’ve had this on disc for years for this very reason,” one user said on X.
Another fan added, “Exactly the reason I own DVDs. They can’t edit those.”
According to the New York Times, most collectors and hobbyists cited the alterations in digital versions as a major reason for purchasing physical media in 2025.
Fans of 1977’s Star Wars, which is another popular holiday title, have been unable to watch the original theatrical cut since director-producer George Lucas has only allowed streaming services to hold the re-release edition.
Despite fans disliking the digital editions, It’s a Wonderful Life continues to prove one of the most popular Christmas movies on streaming. According to FlixPatrol, it was among the top 10 most-watched movies on Amazon Prime during the Christmas period (December 24 and 25) this year.
Viewers discussed the best way to watch It’s a Wonderful Life after discovering there are three versions
