Like the rest of the Pittsburgh Steelers, offensive coordinator Arthur Smith needs to forget the final four games of the regular season ever happened (and ignore that he might be the head coach of the Chicago Bears or New York Jets soon). It’s a new season now, and for his playoff blueprint, Smith must look at the first half of the season, in which Pittsburgh defeated three playoff teams.
After a decisive 6-2 start to the 2024 NFL season, optimism was high for the Steelers. However, a disappointing 4-5 finish has left fans frustrated, with much of their anger directed at Smith. Many Steelers faithful have dubbed him “Matt Canada reincarnated,” drawing comparisons to the much-maligned former OC.
Arthur Smith faces criticism from Steelers fans
The criticism centers on predictable play-calling, lack of creativity, and a seeming inability to adapt mid-game—issues eerily similar to those that plagued the Canada era. While the Steelers finished with a 10-7 record and clinched a playoff spot, fans expected more given the talent on offense.
The unit was poised for a breakout season with veteran Russell Wilson, a receiver corps featuring George Pickens and Pat Freiermuth, and Najee Harris and Jaylen Warren anchoring the ground game. Instead, inconsistency ruled.
Smith, known for his success in Tennessee, was expected to inject life into the Steelers’ offense. Yet, fans are questioning his ability to maximize this team’s potential. Social media is ablaze with debates over Smith’s future and whether head coach Mike Tomlin will make another change at offensive coordinator.
For now, the Steelers’ season hangs in the balance as they prepare for the playoffs. But one thing is clear: Pittsburgh fans demand an offense worthy of their storied franchise. If Smith can’t deliver, the “Matt Canada reincarnated” moniker might stick—and that’s a legacy no coach wants.
