Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
AAP
AAP
Business
Jacob Shteyman and Zac de Silva

'Missed opportunity': tax findings land as talks go on

Political rivals of Anthony Albanese and Jim Chalmers have panned their planned tax reforms. (Susie Dodds/AAP PHOTOS)

Labor has been accused of missing a once-in-a-generation chance to help young Australians as the Greens continue to withhold key support for changes to negative gearing and the capital gains tax.

The final report of a snap two-day parliamentary inquiry into the government's contentious tax changes was handed down on Friday and the recommendations followed a familiar format.

The Labor-led committee said the legislation should be passed by the Senate.

The coalition, in a dissenting report, blasted the government for lying to the Australian people and called for the bill to be scrapped.

tax
Labor will need support from the Greens to get its laws, which include housing tax reforms, passed. (Susie Dodds/AAP PHOTOS)

It wants tax cuts for workers to be extracted from the legislation and passed separately.

The Greens supported reining in tax breaks for investors but criticised the government for grandfathering the concessions.

As the opposition paints itself out of the picture, Labor needs the support of the Greens to get the legislation passed.

With a massive majority in the lower house, the coalition in disarray and a left-wing minor party supportive of ambitious tax reform, the government had a "once-in-a-generation" opportunity for progressive tax changes, Greens Senator Nick McKim wrote in the report.

"Unfortunately, Labor's ambition remained low,'' he said.

"This means that Australia's housing crisis will continue to be more harmful than it should be, for longer than it needs to be.

"The enduring housing crisis will now be Labor's housing crisis."

Greens Senator Nick McKim
Greens Senator Nick McKim says the federal government's proposed tax changes do not go far enough. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)

Senator McKim recommended grandfathering arrangements be limited to one investment property, which would free up more homes for renters and provide extra revenue for deeper tax cuts for workers.

Labor has offered to extend an unrelated inquiry into a proposed overhaul of the NDIS in exchange for Greens support for the tax changes.

But the minor party is reserving its position until it sees amendments which would provide carve-outs for innovative small businesses.

The tax changes, first announced in the May budget, proposed to replace the 50 per cent discount with an inflation indexation model and a minimum 30 per cent tax rate.

That sparked a backlash from startups, which tend to have a negligible initial cost base to index from, meaning their maximum effective tax rate on capital gains would be doubled to nearly 47 per cent.

A composite of business owners
Proposed changes would double the maximum effective tax rate on startups' capital gains. (HANDOUT/ATO and Treasury)

Carve-outs announced on Thursday would allow "innovative businesses" to continue to access the existing 50 per cent capital gains tax discount, while eligibility for the existing 50 per cent active asset reduction for small businesses would be expanded.

The Tech Council, which represents Australia's technology industry including many startups, said the carve-outs were a "constructive response" to the sector's concerns.

But one founder, who asked not to be named so he could speak freely, said the startup community felt the government was making it harder to attract top talent.

The flow of young talent in their 20s or 30s moving to the US would accelerate after the changes, he told AAP.

"Every frontier lab is now chock-full of Australians working in the US," he said.

"You get paid way more, you get taxed less. You get a bit of an adventure."

Senator McKim said the Greens were inclined to support "targeted adjustments" to the tax changes for startups, but the design must enable genuine productive investment and not just open up another avenue for tax planning.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese
Jim Chalmers admits the government has lost some "political paint" over the contentious reforms. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS)

Treasurer Jim Chalmers said Labor had been engaging with the Greens.

"I've learned not to pre-empt outcomes in the Senate until the final votes are counted," he told reporters.

The reforms were worthwhile, but Labor had "lost some political paint" as a result of the campaign against them, Dr Chalmers said.

In a speech to business leaders on the NSW Central Coast, the treasurer tried to play down the impact of the overhaul, pointing to Treasury analysis showing 60 per cent of all net capital gains were earned by just 0.2 per cent of taxpayers.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.