From State v. Conrad, decided Monday by the Ohio Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Judge Eugene Lucci, joined by Judges Matt Lynch and Scott Ylnch:
In 2025, Conrad was living with his girlfriend and their ten-month-old son in Conrad's home in Wickliffe, Ohio. In April 2025, Conrad and his girlfriend were involved in a verbal altercation. After the girlfriend allegedly damaged Conrad's PlayStation console in the basement, Conrad called 911. He informed the dispatcher that he would be armed "because the cops are coming in here." The dispatcher responded, "Do not pick it up with your hands, okay?" Conrad stated, "Absolutely." After ending the 911 call, Conrad armed himself by holstering a handgun on his right hip and then went upstairs to await law enforcement.
When the first officer arrived, Conrad observed him approaching the front door on foot, at which point Conrad opened the door for the officer and informed him that he was armed. The officer responded by stating "pardon me" or "excuse me," and Conrad responded again that he was armed. The officer saw the firearm on Conrad's hip and informed him that he was going to relieve him of the gun. Conrad initially refused, stating, "No you're not," and he changed his stance by turning his right hip away from the officer. Conrad then motioned to or placed his hand on his gun, at which point the officer drew his own firearm. After loudly arguing as to whether Conrad was permitted to be armed, Conrad raised his hands and told the officer to take his gun. Approximately 23 seconds elapsed between the officer entering the home and the officer disarming Conrad.
After disarming Conrad, the officer spoke with him for several minutes regarding his decision to arm himself. During this conversation, Conrad indicated he had armed himself because he believed men were typically arrested when police were called for domestic matters, and he wanted to "eve[n] the playing field" because he was unsure how officers would respond and did not trust them. After speaking with Conrad, the first responding officer joined other officers who had arrived and were speaking to Conrad's girlfriend in the basement. The girlfriend indicated that Conrad had pushed her, and she fell back, bumping her hip against a table, during their dispute.
Conrad was acquitted of domestic violence, but convicted of violating R.C. 2921.31(A), which provides:
