.jpg?width=1200&auto=webp&crop=3%3A2)
The first time I went to the Cayman Islands, I barely left the hotel. To be fair, it was the Ritz-Carlton. There are worse places to be held ‘hostage’.
Days slipped by in a haze of immaculate service, pressed linen, and that particular shade of Caribbean blue that looks suspiciously like a screensaver. Beautiful, obviously. But it was also sealed. Cayman, as far as I understood it then, was a backdrop - pristine, polished, slightly unreal. A place you went to be cocooned, not discovered.
So when I found myself heading back, in the middle of one of London's more punishing stretches of grey, I wasn't expecting a revelation. A nice hotel, some sun, a reset. That would do. What I got instead was something far more interesting.
Because Cayman isn't one place. It's three. Grand Cayman, where most people land, is the version you think you know. Pink and yellow houses. The best fancy restaurants and party spots that a tax-free haven can offer. Palm-lined roads so spotless they look rendered. The kind of place where you start to wonder if someone comes out at night and quietly edits reality.
Even the lighting is curated. At night, a soft amber glow replaces some harsh white streetlights, but I would learn on this trip that it was for ambience, but for turtles. Cayman is one of the Caribbean's most important nesting sites - when hatchlings emerge, they instinctively follow the moonlight to the sea. Bright artificial lights can pull them inland instead.
Over the past few years, the island has transformed quickly - a surge of new hotels, new money, new arrivals. The population has ballooned. Caymanians are technically a minority here; the largest group is Jamaican, followed by a long list of nationalities that reads like an airline departures board.
You feel that immediately. My waitress at lunch was Serbian. Another was Romanian. Our driver, Ian, was from Barbados. Later, I'd chat with someone who I swore was an American with a mid-west accent, was Caymanian born an d bred. It's disorienting at first. Like everyone's in the same play but reading from slightly different scripts.
Anyway, here I was back and told things would be different. For the first couple of days, the sky stayed stubbornly grey - an imported London mood. The island still shimmered, but dulled. It's amazing how much a blue sky does the heavy lifting in the Caribbean.
Then, almost theatrically, the sun arrived. Everything snapped into place. The colours sharpened. The water turned that impossible turquoise. The whole set lit up. And the food. This is where Cayman really makes its case. I was told, more than once, that this is the culinary capital of the Caribbean. It sounds like marketing. It isn't.
At Lobster Pot, one of the island's oldest restaurants, I had fish rundown... rich, coconut-heavy, deeply comforting - with plantain and rice and peas. Jamaican, really. But that's the point. Cayman's cuisine isn't singular; it's a collage. Generations of migration, layered onto a small island, have created something eclectic and consistently delicious. I didn't have a bad meal all week.
Earlier that day, in George Town - the island's capital and its most overtly tourist-facing stretch - I wandered past the cruise port where everything was loud and on-the-nose. It should have been my least favourite part. And yet.
A man directing traffic did so not with urgency, but with choreograph , dancing between cars, throwing in spins and flourishes like a performance rather than a job. At Peppers, that evening, a local haunt I was pointed to when I asked for something ‘real,’ jerk chicken and pork smoked over open flames while Bob Marley played.
The table next to me - all blonde hair and sunburn - turned out not to be tourists at all, but Caymanians. Of course they were. My incredible Filipino waitress summed up the melting pot: ‘Everyone from everywhere is here - and no one ever leaves.’ For those old enough to remember the lyrics of Hotel California, the people come but they never leave is definitely a thing here, but it’s by choice.
Next day at the National Gallery, a small but massively impressive space, I found art pieces work that stopped me in my tracks: bold, intricate, often unexpected. The gallery’s curator guiding me spoke in a clipped British accent. I assumed she was British. She wasn't. She was a local educated by British teachers on an island.
Yah... once you stop trying to make it make sense, it becomes the point. Cayman isn't confused. It's just… multiple.
The gallery itself is quietly brilliant - not a box-ticking cultural stop, but something far more considered. Artists like Nickola McCoy-Snell and Nasaria Suckoo Chollette explore identity, memory and belonging in ways deeply tied to the islands but not limited by them. Experimentation. Voices still shaping what Cayman is and could be.
For a place so often reduced to beaches and balance sheets, a far richer creative pulse runs underneath. One of the highlights of the trip. Cayman began as a maritime outpost, shaped by seafarers rather than plantations. Slavery existed, but the island's development took a different path.
That history comes into sharper focus at the Cayman Islands National Museum around the corner from the National Gallery (everything is around the corner, really) and at Pedro St James, a restored colonial house that traces everything from early settlement to the complexities of its relationship with Britain. They add context to a place that, on the surface, can feel almost too pristine to have a past at all.
Later I dined at Cayman Cabana, where dinner is less about ordering your own plate than sharing the table entirely. Dishes arrived in waves, local produce, fresh seafood, and were passed between strangers who, by the end of the evening, weren't really strangers anymore. Conversation flowed as easily as the food. .. and rum punch.
Then, just as I started to get my bearings, I left. A short flight, barely half an hour, takes you to Cayman Brac. It's like stepping into another country entirely. If Grand Cayman is polished and performative, the Brac is quiet, unrushed, almost stubbornly itself.
Around 2,000 people here. The roads and beaches are genuinely empty. Like, ghost town vibes. Not another person. Idyllic, in the truest sense. Maybe a little too idyllic for me . My friend was ready to move there permanently by lunchtime.
There's a slightly surreal quality to the place. You'll pass a perfectly preserved little post office that looks like it belongs in a painting, then find a café selling matcha lattes. Time folds in on itself.
At NIM Things, a small, brightly coloured house there where you can buy artwork, I met an elderly local who told stories about the island that felt more like folklore than fact. The kind of encounter you can't plan and wouldn't get on Grand Cayman.
Nearby, at Le Soleil d'Or, I wandered through a farm perched on the bluff, tasting fruit straight from the source... guava, Otaheite apple, things I couldn't immediately name. Then came the ‘miracle berry’ - a small, unassuming fruit that flips your taste buds so sour becomes sweet. Suddenly, everything tasted like dessert. Bizarre, brilliant, and one of the most memorable things I did all week.
Earlier, driving across the island, the bluff itself - those dramatic limestone cliffs - gave the landscape a completely different texture to Grand Cayman's flat, polished ease. From the lighthouse, the views stretch endlessly, rugged and wind-brushed. This version of Cayman hasn't been softened or reshaped in quite the same way.
Even lunch felt different here. Simpler. Slower. Chicken, rice and peas, a strong cocktail, and that view. And then there's Little Cayman, smaller still, quieter still... the logical extreme of the same idea. I didn't spend as long there. It's the kind of place you go to properly disappear.
Back on Grand Cayman, the rhythm picked up again. Caves to explore, dramatic, slightly eerie, and the remains of old shipwreck stories at the Wreck of the Ten Sails. The Crystal Caves in particular feel almost theatrical, all stalactites and shadowy pools. One of those places that makes you slow down whether you mean to or not.
And always, food. At Fresca, a low-key spot that absolutely deserves the hype, Caymanian classics sat alongside Japanese influences in a way that shouldn't work but does. At Scratch, a bakery near the airport, a doughnut filled with cassava - a starchy root vegetable -unexpectedly excellent. Even the national drink, swanky (citrus, sugar, ginger), cropped up in different forms, each slightly tweaked.
The hotel this time, Hotel Indigo, is new -barely a year old - all clean lines and contemporary polish - lots of great local artwork on its walls, which is a theme of this island. My room was what they call ‘premier’ - hotel code for standard, but with a slightly better view. Perfectly nice. Annoyingly unmemorable. The service, though, was warm, easy. The kind of place that doesn't try too hard.
Its beach, like most on the island, is technically public. And that's where, for me, Cayman's one real drawback comes in. Small. Popular. You feel it. Unless you're tucked into one of the more secluded hotel stretches, the beaches can get crowded in a way that slightly breaks the spell. Beautiful - the water is undeniable - but not quite the wild, untouched feel of some of its other Caribbean counterparts.
One evening at Pom Pom, the hotel's rooftop, I watched the sun go down with a cocktail made from plantain slightly sweet, slightly savoury, completely unexpected. Btw, it also prides itself on having those turtle lights, but done with the stunning architectural layout of the terrace in mind.
From up there, the island looked softer, quieter, almost a different version of itself.
My trip was coming to an end, and obvs I had to have a send-off spa treatment. I headed to Indigo’s sister hotel - Kimpton right next door and walkable, but I was driven there in a golf buggy, because, why not? The Kimpton Seafire spa was lovely and smoothed out every knot. Then it was food time. Yes, I don’t know how I coped with the hardship.
A final meal in Cayman - lunch at Bonny Moon Beach Club. Toes in the sand. A lobster roll. A frozen cocktail that couldn't decide if it was a piña colada or a strawberry daiquiri - so did both. My last afternoon. Bags practically packed. The kind of timing that feels deliberately cruel.
By then, I felt I knew Cayman. Not a place with a single identity you can neatly summarise. A place of overlaps. Contradictions. Layers that don't always blend but somehow still work.
You come for the picture-perfect version: The colours, the clarity, the ease. And that's there, undeniably. But it’s a mood - three different moods that are hard to define - but more interesting for it.
The Details
- Getting There: British Airways offers the only direct flights from London Heathrow (LHR) to Owen Roberts International (GCM), typically including a short technical stop in Nassau. Prices for a return flight generally start from approximately £731, though you can find deals as low as £665 if you book several weeks in advance.
- The Stay: Rooms at Hotel Indigo Grand Cayman start from approximately £343 per night.
- For all the info and details in the feature visit CIDOT
