Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal Lies, damned lies, and statutes of limitations. Reason · Mar 6
The Fifth Circuit and the Louisiana 10 Commandments Law The en banc court pushes pause--for now Reason · Mar 6
Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal An empty whiskey bottle, a rat in the crosshairs, and the nightmares of HR managers Reason · Feb 20
Fifth Circuit to Hear Oral Argument on the Victims' Families' Challenge to the Dismissal of the Boeing Criminal Case I hope to convince the Fifth Circuit to fully protect the families' rights under the Crime Victims' RIghts Act. Reason · Feb 4
Second Amendment Roundup: 5th Circuit Holds Disarming for Meth Conviction Violates 2nd Amendment No historical analogues justify felon possession ban for drug conviction. Reason · Feb 2
Could the President Invoke the Alien Enemies Act in Response to the "British Invasion" of Rock Stars Like the Beatles? In a crucial appellate court oral argument, the Trump Administration admits that their position says the answer is "yes." The exchange highlights the dangers of judicial deference on judicial invocation of extraordinary emergency powers. Reason · Jan 23
Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal Citizen flag poles, mega-appeals, and land acknowledgments. Reason · Dec 26, 2025
When Courts of Appeals Decide Issues Pending Before the Supreme Court The practice is not consistent. Reason · Dec 19, 2025
Second Amendment Roundup: Supreme Court to decide status of unlawful drug users. ATF’s expansive regulation conflicts with U.S. position that only habitual users are disarmed. Reason · Dec 16, 2025
Journal of Free Speech Law: "Incitement, Enthusiasm, and the Dangers of Negligent Protest," by John Inazu From the "Gitlow v. New York at 100" symposium, held this year at the Arizona State University Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law. Reason · Dec 9, 2025
Some Thoughts On The Texas Gerrymandering Case There is so much to say about LULAC v. Abbott, the recent gerrymandering case decided by a three judge panel… The post Some Thoughts On The Texas Gerrymandering Case appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Nov 23, 2025
Victims' Families Ask the Fifth Circuit to Overturn the Dismissal of the Criminal Case Against Boeing My two petitions for writs of mandamus challenge the Justice Department's violation of the Crime Victims' Rights Act and argue for substantive "public interest" review of prosecutors' dismissal motions. Reason · Nov 18, 2025
The Alien Enemies Act and the Major Questions Doctrine The Trump administration's claims that illegal migration and drug smuggling qualify as an "invasion" or a "predatory incursion" under the Alien Enemies Act go against the major questions doctrine. Reason · Nov 13, 2025
Reason · Nov 9, 2025 The First Circuit Is Not A Denny's According to the Attorney General, the First Circuit's clerk refused to "offer any means of filing" an emergency brief after 5:00 p.m.
Reason · Nov 6, 2025 Judge O'Connor Grants the Government's Motion to Dismiss the Conspiracy Charge Against Boeing … ... but does so reluctantly, calling the objections to the dismissal "compelling" and castigating the Justice Department for its failure "to secure the necessary accountability to ensure the safety of the flying public."
The Texas Tribune · Oct 27, 2025 Federal appeals court will reconsider West Texas A&M drag show ban The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday tossed a three-judge panel's earlier ruling that found the ban violated students' free speech rights. The court's 17 judges will rehear the case.
Reason · Oct 23, 2025 Judge Oldham Wants To Restore A Judiciary Without Horizontal Stare Decisis Judges would find the law, rather than mechanically following every word that appears in a published opinion.
Reason · Oct 1, 2025 A Fifth Circuit Disgrantle in the Alien Enemies Act Case Judge Southwick dissents from the grant of rehearing en banc, Judge Ho cites his Abbott concurrence on the Invasion Clause.
Reason · Sep 4, 2025 Fifth Circuit Rules Trump's Use of Alien Enemies Act is Illegal The 2-1 ruling is in line with most previous court decisions on Trump's invocation of the AEA. Judge Oldham wrote an extremely long, but significantly flawed, dissent.
Reason · Aug 19, 2025 Fifth Circuit Upholds Injunction Against NLRB Proceedings, Distinguishing Humphrey's Executor The Court concludes that limitations on the removal of NLRB Board members and NLRB administrative law judges are both unconstitutional.
Texas Observer · Jul 28, 2025 Rules of the Robe A sharp-eyed retiree uncovered evidence of judicial misconduct by the chief judge of Houston’s busy bankruptcy court. The unusual story highlights how other complaints against judges go ignored.
Reason · Jul 14, 2025 Free Speech Coalition Brings Text, History, and Tradition to the Free Speech Clause Justice Thomas tries to Bruenify free speech doctrine, but I'm not sure it will work.
Reason · Jul 9, 2025 Courts Can Check, and Have Checked, Executives' Military Judgment Katherine Yon Ebright and Leah Tulin of the Brennan Center make the case against judicial deference to Trump's invocation of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798.
Reason · Jul 8, 2025 $725K Settlement in University of North Texas Academic Freedom Case The case settled while motions for summary judgment were pending; the plaintiff, Prof. Timothy Jackson, had prevailed against an earlier motion to dismiss, and the Fifth Circuit had also rejected defendants' appeal as to procedural matters.