After More Than Three Years, Judge Newman's Case Is Transferred To The Eleventh Circuit The case was only transferred after Chief Judge Moore extended Newman's suspension for another year. Reason · 13h ago
Use of Flock Cameras Is Not a Fourth Amendment "Search," District Court Rules The first post-Chatrie ruling on the question. Reason · Sep 16
Eleventh Circuit Holds Qui Tam Relators Are Not "Officers of the United States." What Happens Next? [This post is co-authored with Professor Seth Barrett Tillman.] Over the past decade, many legal challenges have turned on whether… The post Eleventh Circuit Holds Qui Tam Relators Are Not "Officers of the United States." What Happens Next? appeared first on Reason Magazine. Reason · Sep 4
Pro-Palestinian Poster's "Doxing" Claim, Stemming from Her Firing as a Result of Public Criticism, Rejected Some excerpts from Judge Jacqueline Becerra (S.D. Fla.) today in Khorashi v. Beer; the analysis strikes me as correct: This… The post Pro-Palestinian Poster's "Doxing" Claim, Stemming from Her Firing as a Result of Public Criticism, Rejected appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Aug 27
Plaintiff Can't Litigate Claim That "Security Clearance Process" Was Used "as a Pretextual Weapon to Execute an Ideological Purge" From Judge Kyle Dudek (M.D. Fla.) today in Reilly v. U.S. Att'y Gen.: This case presents a conflict between individual… The post Plaintiff Can't Litigate Claim That "Security Clearance Process" Was Used "as a Pretextual Weapon to Execute an Ideological Purge" appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jun 18
Judge Ross Lacked Any Remorse, and The Chief Judge of the Eleventh Circuit Gave Her One Too Many Chances To Correct The Record The latest developments make Judge Ross's situation, and the Eleventh Circuit's response, even worse. Reason · Jun 12
What Judge Wood Did Not Say About Judge Ross's Misconduct (Updated) She says nothing about Judge Ross's dishonesty, nothing about the private reprimand, and nothing about Pauline Newman. Reason · Jun 8
Justice Thomas Faults The Court's Inconsistent Approach to Summary Reversals This aspect of the "shadow" docket is largely ignored. Reason · Jun 1
DOJ Moves To Disqualify Judge Ross In Election Interference Case The Eleventh Circuit's decision to identify a conflict of interest, but not identify the conflicted judge, leaves litigants guessing. Reason · May 30
Who Is The District Court Judge Who Was Privately Reprimanded For Having Loud Sex In Her Chambers With A Law Enforcement Officer From Her District? The clues in the memorandum point to a specific judge. Reason · May 27
Procedural Twist in Kash Patel's Libel Suit Against Substacker Jim Stewartson (Filed in 2023) From today's decision by Chief Judge Andrew Gordon (D. Nev.) in Patel v. Stewartson (for more on the $100K compensatory… The post Procedural Twist in Kash Patel's Libel Suit Against Substacker Jim Stewartson (Filed in 2023) appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Apr 20
Will the Eleventh Circuit Allow the Endangered Species Act to Commandeer the Florida Department of Environmental Protection? A pending case will test whether courts are willing to enforce the anticommandeering doctrine in the context of environmental protection. Reason · Apr 17
Israeli-American Doctor's Federal Conspiracy Claim Against CAIR and Other Critics Can Go Forward for Now From today's decision by Judge Thomas Thrash (N.D. Ga.) in Winer v. Mohammad: This action arises out of alleged defamatory… The post Israeli-American Doctor's Federal Conspiracy Claim Against CAIR and Other Critics Can Go Forward for Now appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jan 27
Federal Officer Removal in Plaquemines Parish Justice Barrett is thinking about Chief Judge Pryor's holding that Mark Meadows could not remove the Georgia criminal prosecution to federal court. Reason · Jan 14
Reason · Dec 19, 2025 When Courts of Appeals Decide Issues Pending Before the Supreme Court The practice is not consistent.
Reason · Nov 18, 2025 COVID Closure of Private Beach Access Constitutes a Taking The Eleventh Circuit concludes "there is no COVID exception to the Takings Clause."
Reason · Oct 28, 2025 Jack Smith Miscalculated The Odds of Drawing Judge Cannon, and After He Lost, Asked SG Prelogar For Permission To Seek Cannon's Removal A new book provides an inside look to the Florida Special Counsel investigation.
Reason · Jul 2, 2025 Florida Can Forbid Transgender High School Math Teacher From Using Feminine Pronouns to Refer to Herself in Class, 11th Circuit Says The appeals court vacated a preliminary injunction that had been based on her First Amendment rights
Reason · Jun 11, 2025 Alabama Defendants in Youth Gender Medicine Case May Disclose Discovery Documents from World Professional Association for Transgender Health Monday's decision by Judge Liles Burke (M.D. Ala.) in Boe v. Marshall dealt with whether the defendants should be able… The post Alabama Defendants in Youth Gender Medicine Case May Disclose Discovery Documents from World Professional Association for Transgender Health appeared first on Reason.com.
Reason · May 16, 2025 Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal Unaccompanied kids, implied causes of action, and filming the police.
Reason · May 8, 2025 Reasonable to Deny Pseudonymity to Plaintiff Who Seeks to Conceal That She Has Epilepsy So holds the Eleventh Circuit.
Reason · Apr 11, 2025 Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal White House press passes, Wikipedia edits, and same-sex weddings.
Reason · Mar 5, 2025 Expressive Discrimination: Universities' First Amendment Right to Affirmative Action — Part 4 The final post in my serial blogging on whether private universities can use a Boy Scouts expressive association theory to have race-based affirmative action.
Reason · Feb 24, 2025 Justices Sotomayor and Gorsuch on the Fourth Amendment and Misdemeanor Arrests "Founding-era common law gave officers no authority to make an 'arrest without a warrant, for a mere misdemeanor not committed in [their] presence.'"
Reason · Jan 17, 2025 Short Circuit: A Roundup of Recent Federal Court Decisions Crypto rules, false statements, and regulatory habitats.