Omar Khan, Art Rooney II and Mike Tomlin have a critical decision to make after the 2024 NFL season comes to a close. I wrote on Monday about why the Pittsburgh Steelers should keep Russell Wilson over Justin Fields. There’s an equally intense case to be made for Fields over Wilson.
Fields presents a compelling choice over veteran Wilson as the Steelers’ front office considers their quarterback options. While Wilson’s experience is impressive, Fields offers distinct advantages that align with the Steelers’ long-term strategy and growth potential.
Justin Fields’ youth and long-term potential
At only 25, Fields has a decade-plus ahead of him, allowing the Steelers to invest in a young quarterback who can evolve within the team’s system. Fields’ age makes him a prime candidate to develop chemistry with younger Steelers players, creating a foundation for sustainable success. With Wilson approaching his 36, his prime years are behind him, while Fields is just beginning to tap into his potential.
Justin Fields’ athleticism and dual-threat ability
Fields is one of the most athletically gifted quarterbacks in the modern league. His dual-threat abilities make him a dangerous weapon in passing and rushing, adding a layer of unpredictability that could invigorate the Steelers’ offense. Fields’ skill set aligns with today’s NFL’s evolving nature, where quarterback mobility and versatility are key elements to an offense. His dynamic playing style would give Pittsburgh’s offense a new edge that would be harder to achieve with Wilson’s more traditional approach.
Justin Fields presents a cost-effective option
Financially, Fields is a more cost-effective choice. Should Fields finish his first season with the Steelers riding pine, there’s the backup quarterback label. Wilson’s veteran status and accomplishments could come with a significant price tag. Should Fields agree to stay with Pittsburgh on an affordable deal, it would allow the Steelers to allocate resources to other areas, such as continuing to strengthen their offensive line or adding elite receivers.
Choosing Fields over Wilson isn’t just about the present; it’s a forward-thinking decision. By committing to Fields, the Steelers can position themselves for future success with a talented, versatile young leader ready to define the next era of Pittsburgh football.
