Eggs, for most of modern supermarket history, have occupied the same mental category as salt or bin bags – things you buy absent-mindedly, rarely linger over and almost never covet.
Which makes the recent reports of shoppers discreetly transferring “posh” eggs into cheaper cartons less a petty crime story than a curious cultural shift. Somewhere between the rise of heritage breeds, rich yolks and artfully pastoral packaging, the humble egg appears to have undergone an unexpected promotion: from kitchen staple to small, brown status symbol.
They’re not the only ones. Salt used to be just salt. Now it’s Maldon, Himalayan or something smoked and hand-harvested from a Scandinavian fjord. Olive oil is the same: Waitrose stocks no fewer than 73 different bottles online (I counted). Oil from Italy, Spain, Greece, infused with chilli, garlic, basil, in plastic, tins, pouches and sprays. It’s no longer just something to fry onions in, but a lifestyle choice.
Eggs, improbably, are the latest victim of this premiumisation. What was once a straightforward purchase now comes in tiers. A box of supermarket own-brand eggs might sit between £1 and £2, still 59 per cent higher than five years ago. Move a shelf above, however, and the numbers change tone. Clarence Court’s Burford Browns are £3.35 for six. St Ewe’s Rich Yolks climb to £4.24. Purely Organic pushes higher still: £5.20 for a half dozen, a price that would have once seemed absurd for something that comes out of the wrong end of a chicken.
The variations do not end there. Rich yolks, golden yolks, big yolks. Free-range, organic, barn. Bluebell Araucana, Chestnut Maran, Leghorn Whites, Blacktails, Longstock Gold. Duck eggs, quail eggs, liquid eggs. The modern egg aisle is no longer just a grocery fixture but a taxonomy of aspiration.
Yet for all the choice, all the subtle signalling of welfare, flavour and superiority, one has to ask: do any of these eggs actually taste that different? Or have eggs simply become another supermarket object onto which we project ideas of quality, virtue and indulgence?
And, more simply, what, exactly, are shoppers paying for when they trade up?
Before blaming this entirely on aspirational packaging, it’s worth noting that egg prices have been climbing for reasons far less whimsical than shell colour or yolk vibrancy.
The economics of egg production have been under pressure for years. Feed costs alone account for roughly 60-70 per cent of the total cost of producing an egg; when those costs doubled in recent years, producers found they were losing money on every dozen laid.
At the same time, energy bills, which underpin everything from heating sheds to processing stations, have shot up by more than 50 per cent, while labour, packaging and chick replacements have all added to the burden. In late 2025, the average UK farm-gate price paid for eggs was around 148p per dozen, a small increase on the year before but far above historical levels.
Then there’s bird flu, which has transformed from occasional disruption to recurring structural risk. In the past couple of seasons, the UK has seen dozens of outbreaks of highly pathogenic avian influenza on commercial farms, from confirmed cases in North Yorkshire and Devon to 30 swans found dead on the Thames.
When an outbreak is confirmed on a site, all birds are typically culled to stop further transmissions, and protection zones are imposed around affected premises to prevent the movement of potentially infected birds.
These responses are necessary for animal health, but they remove laying hens from the supply chain, squeezing output and reducing the number of eggs available on the market. Global outbreaks have also contributed to this pattern, with tens of millions of poultry culled in the US and similar pressures felt in Europe.
Yet these genuine economic shocks alone do not account for the curious complexity of the modern egg aisle. While producers grapple with volatility, retailers have been busy turning eggs into something rather more theatrical.
Clarence Court is perhaps the clearest symbol of this shift. With crown-stamped shells, breed names and deep bronze hues, the brand presents eggs as objects of connoisseurship, rather than mere ingredients. Burford Browns, Old Cotswold Legbar, Leghorn Whites, Seabright Sage and Cornish Blues – the language alone reframes the category. These are not just eggs. They are eggs with provenance, identity and implied superiority.
But they are also… just eggs. Much of this visible difference is rooted in genetics rather than gastronomics. Shell colour, for instance, is a function of breed, not quality – a Leghorn white is no less “egg-like” than a supermarket’s own brand. Certain heritage or slower-laying hens may produce eggs with marginally richer characteristics, but the biological gap between breeds is far narrower than the marketing poetry might suggest, and the impact on flavour is negligible.
St Ewe’s Rich Yolk eggs perform a slightly different manoeuvre. Their appeal rests on colour – those deep, burnished orange yolks that consumers instinctively read as richer, tastier, somehow better. In reality, yolk intensity is largely dictated by the hen’s diet, specifically the presence of carotenoids in feed ingredients such as maize and marigold. The effect on flavour is, at most, subtle. The effect on perception, enormous. A rich yolk tells you more about what the hen had for breakfast than what you will taste at dinner.
Purely Organic, by contrast, represents a very different, and arguably more straightforward, kind of premium. Free-range systems, once considered the upgrade, have largely become the baseline, with hens given daytime outdoor access, stocking densities capped and cages absent altogether. Organic certification pushes further still. Birds must be fed organic-certified diets, housed under stricter welfare standards and managed with tight restrictions on routine antibiotic use.
That carries unavoidable costs, which is why organic eggs reliably occupy the highest price tier. But the logic is clearer. Consumers are not being sold more photogenic yolks, but a farming philosophy built around welfare. Whether shoppers feel inclined to pay for that distinction is a personal calculation. The justification, at least, is tangible.
Nutritionally, however, the distinctions between pricing tiers are far less dramatic than the shelves might imply. Waitrose’s most basic – and cheapest – Essential Free-Range White Eggs deliver roughly 66 calories per boiled egg, alongside 6.5g of protein and 4.4g of fat. Clarence Court’s Burford Browns, St Ewe’s Rich Yolks and Purely Organic’s eggs land in near-identical nutritional territory.
Eggs, it turns out, are still one of the most nutritionally efficient foods in the supermarket, regardless of branding. Protein, fats and micronutrients arrive in broadly consistent proportions whether the shell is chalk-white, chestnut-brown or Instagram-friendly sage green. The price ladder, by contrast, stretches dramatically. What changes most conspicuously is not the nutritional payload, but how an egg makes you feel when you buy it. Or nick it.
Which brings us back to the shoppers relocating “posh eggs” into cheaper boxes. The whole exercise is slightly baffling, and, well, pointless. However handsome the shell, however burnished the yolk, the differences that actually matter are small, if not non-existent.
Scrambled eggs will still taste like scrambled eggs, even if they’ve come out of a colourful box. Fried egg on toast will still taste like fried egg on toast, even if the yolk looks richer. The Victoria sponge will not rise to new aristocratic heights, just because it’s come from a court. However deluxe the shell, it won’t change your macros. No egg can outrun its own ordinariness.
In that sense, the great egg swap is less a supermarket scam than a misunderstanding. People aren’t stealing eggs – they’re stealing what the eggs say about them.
Chris Bosh says he’s ‘lucky to be alive’ after ‘waking up covered in my own blood’
How to make Nadiya Hussain’s delicious croissant berry pudding slices
Pets can improve the health of older adults – but also strain their finances: poll
This is how to make sure you never make a mistake buying wine again
Tim Spector: Why food affects your mood – not just your calories
What happens when Love Island meets MasterChef? ITV’s The Heat tries it
