A legal battle over a broken playground swing in Springdale, Pennsylvania, has sparked an online debate over childhood play, parental liability and whether minor property damage should lead to criminal charges. On Aug. 28, a local judge dismissed criminal mischief charges against two sisters, ages 10 and 12, after a swing chain at a local park broke while the girls were playing.
According to Guessing Headlights, the incident happened at Veterans Memorial Park in Springdale, a borough northeast of Pittsburgh. The girls’ mother, Katie Huss, said her daughters were at the park with a group of local children. In a game familiar to generations of kids, two children sat on the swing while the others twisted the chains tightly so they could spin around and get dizzy.