Without question, the biggest mystery on The Young and the Restless is the true identity of Aristotle Dumas. Victor (Eric Braeden) and Michael (Christian LeBlanc) suspect the mystery businessman could be Tucker (Trevor St. John), pointing to the facts that Aristotle seems to have an interest in the Winters clan, there are similarities between Tucker’s former Glissade and one of Aristotle’s businesses and the billionaire enigma has an interest in Chancellor.
There’s also a theory among fans that Aristotle Dumas could be Cane (last played by Daniel Goddard). Jack (Peter Bergman) was the first to mention that Aristotle arrived on the business scene between five and six years ago, which happens to align with Cane’s departure from Genoa City. It wouldn’t come as a surprise if Cane were back with a renewed interest in Chancellor and a desire to reconnect with Lily (Christel Khalil). Although Goddard is currently making a debut on General Hospital, we can’t rule out that he could pull double duty on both soaps, or Cane could be recast.
