Research published today shows that much of the wealth of the Guardian’s founder and his backers was connected to transatlantic slavery
The Scott Trust apologises for the origins of the wealth used to found the Guardian and the part its founders played in the slavery economy
Programme of restorative justice set out by the Scott Trust for the next decade
The Scott Trust has today published its review into the Guardian’s historical connections with transatlantic slavery.
Academic research, commissioned in late 2020 by the Trust and carried out in three stages by the University of Nottingham’s Institute for the Study of Slavery and the University of Hull’s Wilberforce Institute for the Study of Slavery and Emancipation, sets out a range of connections between transatlantic slavery and John Edward Taylor, the journalist who founded the Manchester Guardian in 1821, and the other Manchester businessmen who funded the newspaper’s creation.
The review establishes that:
Taylor had links to slavery through partnerships in cotton manufacturing and merchant firms which imported raw cotton produced by enslaved people in the Americas. Researchers reviewed an invoice book showing that Shuttleworth, Taylor & Co. received cotton from specific plantations from the Sea Islands region of the United States.
Nine of the eleven men who loaned Taylor money to found the Manchester Guardian had similar links to the slavery economy through their commercial interests in Manchester’s cotton and textiles industry.
In addition to having interests in the cotton industry, one of these men, Sir George Philips, was an enslaver of people as co-owner of a sugar plantation in Hanover, Jamaica. In 1835, Philips unsuccessfully attempted to claim compensation from the British government for 108 people enslaved on the plantation.
The other two backers are likely to have been cotton merchants but researchers were unable to find detailed histories of the men within the stipulated time frame.
The Scott Trust has issued a response to the findings, acknowledging and apologising for the origins of the wealth used to found the Guardian, and for the fact that the Guardian’s editorial positions in its early decades sometimes served to support the cotton industry, and therefore the exploitation of enslaved people.
The Scott Trust has today set out proposals for a programme of restorative justice. Over the next decade, the Trust intends to:
fund an increase in the scope and ambition of Guardian reporting on the Caribbean, South America and Africa, and on Black communities in the UK and US.
create a substantial restorative justice fund to support community projects and programmes in the southeastern US Sea Islands/Gullah Geechee region and Jamaica over the next ten years. This fund will be developed with extensive community input and consultation.
fund the Guardian Foundation to expand its industry-leading journalism training bursary scheme. The Scott Trust Bursary currently funds three journalism masters courses and paid training placements at GNM each year for aspiring journalists in the UK from underrepresented backgrounds. Additional funding will create three new places each year for Black prospective journalists in the UK, and create equivalent schemes in the Guardian’s offices in the US and Australia.
explore and fund a new global news sector fellowship programme for mid-career Black journalists.
help improve public understanding of transatlantic slavery’s ongoing impact on Manchester’s and Britain’s history – and of the debates around reparations and restorative justice, through partnerships and community programmes, with a strong focus on Manchester, the city in which we were founded.
continue to fund research of these histories, through a three-year partnership with the Wilberforce Institute at the University of Hull.
The Scott Trust expects to invest more than £10 million in this work over the next decade, with millions of pounds dedicated specifically to a restorative justice fund supporting descendant communities in the Sea Islands and Jamaica.
Ole Jacob Sunde, chair of the Scott Trust, said:
“The Scott Trust is deeply sorry for the role John Edward Taylor and his backers played in the slavery economy. We recognise that apologising and sharing these facts transparently is only the first step in addressing the Guardian’s historical links to transatlantic slavery, which was a crime against humanity.
“In response to the findings, the Scott Trust is committing to fund a restorative justice programme over the next decade, which will be designed and carried out in consultation with descendant communities in the US, Jamaica, the UK and elsewhere, centred on long-term initiatives and meaningful impact.
“These are significant new facts about the Guardian’s origin story, and they must therefore inform our purpose as we move forward, pushing us to do more to reflect the society we aspire to, alongside the radical history of Peterloo which originally inspired our values and our mission.”
Alongside the research, the Guardian today publishes a major journalism series, Cotton Capital exploring the connections between slavery and the Guardian’s founders, the city of Manchester, and Britain more widely. A range of articles, features, podcasts and films will launch as part of this series in the weeks ahead, including a dedicated print supplement published free with the Guardian this Saturday (1 April).
In an article published today, Katharine Viner, editor-in-chief, Guardian News & Media, writes:
“We are facing up to, and apologising for, the fact that our founder and those who funded him drew their wealth from a practice that was a crime against humanity.
“As we enter our third century as a news organisation, this awful history must reinforce our determination to use our journalism to expose racism, injustice and inequality, and to hold the powerful to account.”
The Guardian is holding a special event to explain and discuss the findings, this Thursday 30 March at 7:00pm (GMT). Joseph Harker, the Guardian’s senior editor for diversity and development, will chair a panel of speakers including: Katharine Viner, the Guardian’s editor-in-chief; David Olusoga, one of Britain’s foremost historians and a Scott Trust member; Dr Cassandra Gooptar of the Wilberforce Institute, University of Hull; and Maya Wolfe-Robinson, editor of Cotton Capital. Click here for more information and to register.
The programme of restorative justice work will be overseen by a new programme director to be appointed shortly. The Scott Trust is establishing an advisory panel of experts to guide and review its programme of work on an ongoing basis. The first four members of the advisory panel are:
Dr. Cassandra Gooptar. Dr. Gooptar is a post-doctoral research fellow at the University of Hull’s Wilberforce Institute, and is the author of the reports looking into the Guardian’s links with slavery commissioned by the Scott Trust.
Reverend Professor Keith Magee. Keith Magee is chair of the Guardian Foundation, a Senior Fellow in Culture and Justice at University College London, and Chair and Professor of Practice in Social Justice at Newcastle University
Professor Olivette Otele. Professor Otele is a world-renowned historian and author, and is Distinguished Research Professor of the Legacies and Memory of Slavery at SOAS, University of London.
Professor Matthew Smith. Professor of History and Director of the Centre for the Study of the Legacies of British Slavery at University College London, having previously worked at the University of the West Indies in Jamaica as Professor of Caribbean History.
The Trust expects to appoint other external members to this panel in due course.
The Trust will consult widely on its proposals, inviting descendant communities in the US, Jamaica and the UK, and GNM employees, experts, community organisations and others to share views on the research and the proposed programme of work.
For more information please contact: legacies@theguardian.com
Notes to editors
About the Scott Trust
The core purpose of the Scott Trust is to secure the financial and editorial independence of the Guardian in perpetuity. The Trust was originally created in 1936 to secure the financial and editorial independence of the Guardian in perpetuity and to safeguard the journalistic freedom and liberal values of the Guardian, free from commercial or political interference.
The Trust was reconstituted in 1948 and in 2008 replaced with The Scott Trust Limited, a limited company with the same protections for the Guardian enshrined in its constitution. The Scott Trust is the sole shareholder in Guardian Media Group. Its profits are reinvested in journalism and do not benefit a proprietor or shareholders.
About the research
In July 2020 the Scott Trust commissioned an expert academic review to examine possible historic links between transatlantic slavery and the Manchester Guardian’s founders.
The research was conducted in three stages – first by Dr Sheryllynne Haggerty and Dr Cassandra Gooptar of the University of Nottingham’s Institute for the Study of Slavery, and later by Dr Gooptar and Professor Trevor Burnard of the University of Hull’s Wilberforce Institute for the Study of Slavery and Emancipation.
The first phase of research focused largely on John Edward Taylor’s business investments and partnerships, and those of the eleven other men who loaned him money to found the Manchester Guardian. The second phase of work looked at the wider personal, familial and commercial networks of these individuals, the wider cotton trade in Manchester generally in the 19th century and the global networks which facilitated its growth. The third phase of research focused in part on identifying links with plantations in the southeastern United States and Jamaica, and attempting to identify, if possible, some of the enslaved.
About this project
The academic research and restorative justice proposals have been overseen by a committee of Scott Trust members: historian, writer and broadcaster David Olusoga, barrister and former deputy mayor of London Matthew Ryder KC, Guardian editor-in-chief Katharine Viner, and Scott Trust chair Ole Jacob Sunde; and by a team of Guardian editorial and commercial staff, led by: senior editor for diversity and development Joseph Harker and chief communications and marketing officer Brendan O’Grady. Maya Wolfe-Robinson has been the editor of Cotton Capital.
Former Scott Trust chair, Alex Graham, initiated the review and was a member of this committee until stepping down from the Scott Trust board in 2021. The Scott Trust has discussed the proposals at regular intervals at its board meetings during 2022 and early 2023.
