A spare dresser sits in the garage because your daughter might need it someday, while Grandma’s dishes occupy three boxes waiting for a grandchild who has never actually asked for them. Keeping useful possessions can feel responsible, generous and even frugal because getting rid of something only to buy it again later seems wasteful. But “free” storage isn’t always free, particularly when belongings consume garages and spare rooms, get moved from house to house or eventually require a paid storage unit. At some point, you can spend more protecting a $200 piece of furniture than it would cost to replace it if someone genuinely needed one years from now. The better question isn’t whether somebody might want an item someday—it’s whether keeping it until that hypothetical day makes financial and practical sense.