In Smith & Wesson Brands, Inc. v. Estados Unidos Mexicanos, the Mexican government is suing several of the most popular American firearm manufacturers in an attempt to hold them liable for violence committed by Mexican drug cartels in Mexico. The Mexican government seeks billions of dollars in damages and the imposition of extensive gun controls in America.
This post is coauthored with Joseph Greenlee, who is a research associate at the Independence Institute (where I work) and Director of the Office of Litigation Counsel for the National Rifle Association's Institute for Legislative Action.
We filed an amicus brief on behalf of the National Rifle Association, FPC Action Foundation, and Independence Institute in support of the American manufacturers. The State of Montana, joined by 25 more states, filed a brief as well. In response to these two briefs, a group of social science, medical, and legal scholars supporting the Mexican government joined a brief filed by Crowell & Moring aimed at refuting our claims. This post addresses their arguments.
