Exemption on a case-to-case basis will be provided from Aadhaar based payment system (ABPS) for MGNREGS workers, the Union Rural Development Ministry said in a statement in response to The Hindu news story that 34.8% of total registered workers and 12.7% of active workers remain ineligible for this mandatory payment method as government.
The push for ABPS has also led to a high rate of job card deletions, as evidenced by anecdotal evidence and ground reports. The Hindu reported that 7.6 crore workers have been deleted since April 2022, as per data collated by Lib Tech India, a consortium of academics and activists. The Ministry, in its response, asserted, “Job Cards of household can be deleted only in certain specific conditions but not due to ABPS. Updation/deletion of Job Cards is a regular exercise conducted by the states/UTs.”
The Congress called the Union government’s decision a “cruel New Year gift”. Party general secretary (Communication) Jairam Ramesh accused the government of “weaponsing technology” to “exclude crores of the poorest and marginalised Indians from earning a basic income”.
“The Prime Minister’s well-known disdain for MNREGA has translated into a slew of experiments designed to use technology as a weapon to exclude - such as the digital attendance (NMMS), ABPS, drone monitoring and the proposed integration of facial recognition to NMMS,” he observed. He added that no due consultation or scientific piloting was done before unleashing these “experiments” on crores of Indians.
The Congress reiterated its demand for the order to be revoked. “The Indian National Congress reiterates its demand of 30th August, 2023 that the Modi government should stop weaponsing technology, especially Aadhaar, to deny the most vulnerable Indians their social welfare benefits, release delayed wage payments and implement open muster rolls and social audits to improve transparency,” Mr. Ramesh demanded.
In response to Mr. Ramesh’s allegation, the government in a statement on Monday night said that Aadhaar seeding of beneficiaries is a “continuous process and is done as a de-duplication exercise to authenticate the genuine beneficiaries” and “make the benefits of the social welfare schemes available only to genuine beneficiaries”. The government reiterated its earlier claim that in comparison to account-based payment where the success rate is 98%, the success rate is 99.55% where the Aadhaar is enabled for Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT).
It has also dismissed a study by LibTech India, which Mr. Ramesh also quoted, which noted that the benefit of the ABPS is limited. The Ministry argued that in terms of scale, even the 3% gain is very significant.
