Should kitchen counter colors match an island? Interior designers weigh in on whether to complement or contrast

Should kitchen counter colors match an island? Here are two pictures of kitchen islands and countertops - one marble kitchen island with black countertops and white cabinets and one marble island with white countertops and black cabinets behind it.

If you're about to renovate, you might be wondering if matching your kitchen's perimeter counter color to that of your island's counter is a good idea — or whether going for a contrast is smarter, or more on trend. 

The truth is, there's no definitive answer. I spoke with two interior designers who are experienced in renovating kitchens, and they both agree that while either can work, both will bring distinctly different results which will impact the overall look and feel of your space.