Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Entertainment
Arifa Akbar

Scene Unseen review – cabaret song cycle seems both too short and too long

A compelling presence … l to r, Joseph Atkins and Jessica Walker in Scene Unseen.
A compelling presence … l to r, Joseph Atkins and Jessica Walker in Scene Unseen. Photograph: David Lefeber

It is reassuring to see online shows being made beyond pandemic necessities and especially the productions that push at the boundaries, as this one does.

Written by Jessica Walker and Joseph Atkins (she also sings while he plays the piano), and directed by James Dacre, it is staged as an intimate cabaret and combined with scenes of animation. Its story takes us through issues of gender identity, sexuality, sexual assault and Walker’s early relationship with a father who kept her existence a secret from his family.

In a co-production by Royal & Derngate in Northampton and English Touring Opera, Walker is a compelling presence with a strong voice, bringing strains of opera to the cabaret sound.

But this show seems both too short – giving us what feels like disjointed vignettes with gaps in between – and repetitive in its thoughts and phrases. There are recurring dreams, musings and observations but these lack focus, and there is little dramatic pull to the narrative overall. As a result, the pace is ponderous even at just under an hour long.

The singing feels slightly redundant, too – a way of imparting prosaic information much of the time and the shorter spoken parts feel like a relief, when they come.

A wedding bookends the production but we learn nothing of Walker’s wife – how and when they met, for example, although she tells us more about previous partners. Neither do we get any real sense of her shadowy father or a sketchy portrait of the “shoe-stall couple” whose presence reminds her that relationships can be lonely, too. The sexual assault is disturbing but the accompanying lyrics jar as she tries to escape (“I’m doing the escapologist’s tango”).

Filmed by David Lefeber, the camera brings various angles including aerial shots but it is not enough to sustain us visually. Thomas Hicks’s black and white animation is immensely evocative but does not stay long enough to draw us into its world. Perhaps it would have worked better if the entire song cycle were set against these beguiling illustrations so that they could cast their spell on us.

Available online until 12 November.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.