Nineteen-year-old Sade Robinson was excited about her first date with a new guy she’d met while out with friends. But it quickly turned into a nightmare, with the Milwaukee college student never returning home from dinner and drinks.
The very next day, April 2, 2024, Robinson's leg was discovered on the shores of Lake Michigan in Cudahy's Warnimont Park – her toes still coated with pink polish. Her car was found set on fire, and Maxwell Anderson, the 34-year-old man she went out with, was spotted on security cameras at a nearby bus station.