Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Manchester Evening News
Manchester Evening News
Entertainment
Emma Gill

My kids put M&S and Morrisons Jubilee Corgi cakes to the test - this one took the crown

They're up there with the most popular celebration cakes so it's no surprise that retailers have been transforming their caterpillars into corgis to mark the Queen's Platinum Jubilee.

Aldi has stayed out of this one - poor Cuthbert's probably avoiding the limelight after his court case. This time it's Morrisons and M&S going head-to-head with their cake creations.

While Morrisons has launched Clarence the Corgi cake to honour the occasion, M&S, home of the original Colin the Caterpillar, has gone double whammy with two cakes in one. One half of the M&S creation is a corgi and the other is its Connie the Caterpillar transformed into the Queen herself.

READ MORE:

As expected both shop cakes have been in high demand ahead of the big day and when M&S shared a snap of its Limited Edition Corgi meets Jubilee Connie the Caterpillar cake on Instagram, it racked up thousands of likes in just a couple of hours from customers eager to get their hands on one.

Limited Edition Corgi meets Jubilee Connie the Caterpillar from M&S (Manchester Family / MEN)

Essentially what you're getting with any caterpillar cake is a swiss roll covered in chocolate - but we all know there's a lot more to it than that. Like most children, my two are fans of cake and at 13 and 11, let's just say they've eaten their fair share of the stuff to know what makes a decent slice.

So I let them give both a taste to see what they thought. Obviously with my own 43 years' experience of cake eating, my input would be vital to this little sugary experiment.

So how do they rate?

On looks alone both would make a great centre piece for any Jubilee gathering and if you're trying to keep costs down then you get more cake for your money with Morrisons' Clarence - £6 for 900g as opposed to 720g for £10 with M&S.

The M&S creation is two cakes in one (Manchester Family / MEN)

But we all agreed that as delightful as Clarence is, it's the M&S duo who stand out and would make a bigger impression on your party table. It was genius idea to have Connie in on the act as the Queen, as well as making Colin into a Corgi.

The only downside to them facing one another inside the box is that their faces have rubbed up against each other leaving remnants of Corgi's brown chocolate on the Queen and vice versa - a right royal mucky pup.

As for Clarence, who is decorated with red, blue and white sprinkles, his face is edible too, but icing rather than chocolate. Only my son preferred that to the delicious chocolate faces of Connie and Corgi mind and if you've tasted the M&S chocolate encasing Colin before - and those white chocolate feet - then you'll know why. This is not just any old chocolate.

Morrisons has launched Clarence the Corgi cake to honour the occasion (Manchester Family / MEN)

Don't get me wrong, Clarence was tasty, but he could have done with a bit more of the gooey stuff and less of the cake. While everyone has their own preference on cake to filling ratios (I'm sure that's a thing with the Mary Berrys of this world) we all preferred the taste and texture that the larger quantity of chocolate buttercream gave to Connie and Corgi.

The dog lover in me feels mean pitting them against each other and like with any pooch the right home can be found for both of these cakes. It just happens that in our chocolate-loving household, it's Corgi and Jubilee Connie who take the crown.

Morrisons is selling Clarence, 900g, for £6. M&S has its Limited Edition Corgi meets Jubilee Connie the Caterpillar, 720g, in store for £10 or available via Ocado here.

M&S limited edition shortbread biscuits tins, top, and Morrisons' cupcake selection below (Manchester Family / MEN)

Both have a wide range of Jubilee food and gifts available including Morrisons' Jubilee cupcakes, decorated with sprinkles and Union Jacks and costing £5 for a pack of nine. It's also selling a giant cookie for £7 and individual Jubilee shortcake crown biscuits for £1 each.

At M&S there are some limited edition Jubilee biscuit tins costing £5 each and filled with Jubilee themed shortbread, an Ultimate Afternoon Tea Selection for £20, sandwich platters and more.

To keep on top of the news and events for families in Manchester, sign up to the Manchester Family newsletter here.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.