Almost a year after publishing its Universities and Scotland report, the Scottish Affairs Committee has received the UK Government’s response - with complaints over pertinent questions left unanswered and solutions to enhance the Scottish sector rejected.
Specifically, Westminster rejected the committee’s recommendation that Scottish institutions should have a greater representation within UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), including a seat on the UKRI board.
The committee believes this would have been a “quick win” to get the voice of Scottish academia reflected in the UK’s main research and development agency.
While the government accepted the committee’s recommendation that funding of the Turing Scheme should continue for the coming years, it did not engage with recommendations around facilitating international student and academic staff placements.
The UK and Scotland benefited in these areas previously under the EU’s Erasmus+ programme.
A statement from the committee noted that attracting international talent is further disincentivised by the high costs of the Global Talent Visa.
Failure to lower the cost could lead to Scottish institutions losing their competitive edge as an attractive place to work, it argued, adding that the government rejected the opportunity to bring the cost of the visa in line with other countries, such as France.
The committee has written a follow-up letter seeking clarity on points around student and academic staff exchange through the Turing Scheme, Scottish representation within UKRI and the UK’s participation in Horizon Europe.
Committee chair Pete Wishart said: “Scottish universities are a regular feature in league tables of the top UK universities, attracting talent from all around the world.
“However, as our committee identified last year, losing out on academic and research partnerships as a result of Brexit and sky high visa fees are significantly damaging our ability to continue to attract the brightest and best - if Scottish universities are to continue punching above their weight, they need appropriate support from government.”
He added: “The UK Government’s response to our report contains many words but says very little - there is no good reason why Scottish representation is lacking within decision-making at UKRI, and making the UK a more competitive place for international students and academics to come is surely only a positive move.”
Don't miss the latest headlines with our twice-daily newsletter - sign up here for free.
