2025's a big year for late bloomers finding love on reality TV. First, there was the Korean reality show Better Late Than Single, and now there's Are You My First?, Hulu's latest unscripted series from the producers of Love Island USA. Hosted by Bachelor alums Kaitlyn Bristowe and Colton Underwood, the new reality series is a classic tropical dating show that takes a bunch of hot people and drops them into a villa to flirt and fall in love. However, the stakes are higher because they're all looking for their first (physical, at least) love.
Like its international counterpart, the surprising sincerity of Are You My First? belies its eyebrow-raising title (and Iain Stirling-style voiceover narration). Especially after a summer of intense reality drama, the cast of this series feels like a breath of fresh air, with a handful of ready-made TV personalities (and alums from other shows) sprinkled in. Leave your expectations at the door; there are way fewer corny challenges and way more genuine conversations (and sex-education trivia) than you'd expect.
