Man allegedly choked his wife’s fiancée to death in a motel parking lot. 7 years later, it all comes crashing down

What began in 2019 as the unexplained disappearance of a woman from a motel in Pennsylvania is now a murder case against her fiancée’s husband. Seven years later, the police have learned a terrifying truth about the case.

Here is the fuller picture, according to the story that has emerged in September 2026. Amanda Snyder and Kimberley Gsell, 38, were engaged in 2019, though Amanda’s marriage to David Snyder had not ended. The couple had Room 312 at the Harrisburg Pike Rodeway Inn from Friday, September 27, 2019, until that Sunday.