Israeli Committee Approves Bill To Limit Supreme Court’s Use Of Reasonableness

Likud party member of Knesset Tali Gottlieb speaks to supporters during a pro reform demonstration earlier this year. Thousands of Israelis came out in support of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's judicial overhaul plan on Thursday, blocking a highway in Tel Aviv after months of anti-government protests convulsed the country. EYAL WARSHAVSKY/SOPA IMAGES/LIGHTROCKET VIA GETTY IMAGES. 

The Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee late Wednesday night approved for final readings a bill to limit the Supreme Court’s use of the reasonableness standard.

“With nine lawmakers voting in favor and seven opposed, the amendment to Basic Law: The Judiciary will now head back to the plenum for the second and third readings needed for it to become law,” said JNS.

Opposition Knesset members caused a scene during the deliberations over the bill, which would bar “reasonableness” as a legal justification for judges to reverse decisions made by the Cabinet, ministers and “other elected officials as set by law.”

“The standard is legally vague and has been used by the court to encroach upon the government’s authority. Opponents say the legislation will erode Israel’s system of checks and balances and lead to abuse of power,” said critics. 

MK Simcha Rothman (center), head of the Constitution, Law and Justice Committee, with MK Ofir Katz (left) after the panel met in Jerusalem, July 19, 2023. The Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee approved for final readings a bill to limit the Supreme Court’s use of the reasonableness standard. YONATAN SINDEL/FLASH90. 

Members of the opposition shouted “Shame” and Labor MK Gilad Kariv was removed after waving pictures of the International Criminal Court and accusing committee chairman Simcha Rothman (Religious Zionism) of neglecting IDF soldiers.

“What is currently on the table is a bad law that violates the basic rights of Israeli citizens and may harm their security as well,” said Yisrael Beiteinu MK Yulia Malinovsky.

“It is not too late to open the text to revision because what is currently in the text completely neuters the legal system and deprives the citizens of Israel of any tools to deal with the bullying of the politicians,” said the lawmaker.

The vote came after a marathon session with almost 28,000 reservations (proposed amendments) lodged by opponents of the bill.

Coalition members welcomed the approval.

“We did it. A holiday for democracy and all of Israel! Many thanks to the dedicated chairman of the committee, Simcha Rothman, for the hard work, on Monday in the plenary!” said coalition whip MK Ofir Katz (Likud).

Rothman replied: “Your mobilization together with that of the coalition was the basic prerequisite for us to reach this moment.”

Produced in association with Jewish News Syndicate

Edited by Judy J. Rotich and Newsdesk Manager