Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Politics
Helena Horton

Is Richard Tice’s picture AI-manipulated? Here are five giveaways

AI manipulated image of Reform UK supporters as posted by Richard Tice
After Tice posted this picture on Sunday, X users lined up to ask whether the image was legitimate or ‘pure AI slop’. Illustration: @TiceRichard

***

Three men stand in the foreground holding ‘Vote Reform’ signs
AI manipulated image of Reform UK supporters as posted by Richard Tice. Illustration: @TiceRichard

After Richard Tice posted a picture of an apparent Reform campaign event on Sunday, experts and social media detectives took a closer look and concluded from a variety of telltale signs that the image had either been edited or generated by artificial intelligence. Here are some of the elements that critics called into question.

***

1. Mangled fingers

A woman in a yellow dress and denim jacket
On closer inspection, one woman has six fingers on one hand. Illustration: @TiceRichard

One woman has six fingers on one hand and extra long ones on the other. The man in the beige jacket has three extremely long fingers which look like sausages. AI often gets fingers wrong.

***

2. Garbled signs

Closeups of black and yellow ‘Vote Reform’ signs
The signs are supposed to read ‘Get Starmer Out’. Illustration: @TiceRichard

The signs are supposed to read “Get Starmer Out” but the text reads more like “Get Stuppence out”. The Reform arrow on many of them is also wonky. AI image programs often struggle with generating or editing text.

***

3. Blurred faces

Three men smiling, with two holding black and yellow ‘Vote Reform’ signs
Lots of the faces of the campaigners appear smeared and blurred. Illustration: @TiceRichard

Lots of the faces of the campaigners appear smeared and blurred, with one man appearing to have closed, wonky eyes.

***

4. Perfect lines and geometric patterns

Zoomed-in image of people’s shoes
The concrete pattern is perfectly geometric, which is a sign of AI, say experts. Illustration: @TiceRichard

The pixel-perfect vertical lines on the railings are suspicious, and if you zoom in on the concrete you can see the pattern is perfectly geometric, which is a sign of AI.

***

5. Mysteriously floating objects

Five men stand on a street, with two holding ‘Vote Reform’ signs
The man in the white jacket does not appear to be holding his sign. Illustration: @TiceRichard

The man in the red T-shirt and white jacket does not appear to be holding his “Get Stuppence Out” sign, instead it is floating in front of him.

***

Reform UK has denied the picture is AI-generated. A spokesperson said: “The photograph is real, however the version Richard Tice posted was slightly edited using AI, mainly to increase the brightness.”

Read more on this story here
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.