Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Chronicle Live
Chronicle Live
National
Emma Munbodh & Sophie Finnegan

Investigation launched over claims energy firms have increased direct debits for millions of customers

An investigation has been launched into some of the country's biggest energy firms over claims they have increased direct debits for millions of customers.

Following a surge in the price cap, Ofgem, the market regulator, said that there have been "troubling signs" that some companies are overcharging customers. It's claimed some have increased households' direct debits by more than necessary to cover a £693 increase in average bills.

Although monthly charges can be increased by suppliers, it must be according to the household's usage. You also must be notified of this beforehand - usually at least 10 days before it goes up, the Mirror reports.

Read more: Martin Lewis fan explains how they saved £213 by making simple bill changes

Customers can dispute this amount, or submit an exact meter reading to ensure the increase is linked to their actual usage. Ofgem also said some businesses may have been directing customers to tariffs that are not in their best interests.

Charging customers more than necessary allows suppliers to build up a cash safety net in case wholesale prices surge again in the wake of the Ukraine crisis. The practice is banned because it is unfair to the consumer. Ofgem is now launching a series of reviews to assess whether energy retailers are complying with these rules.

Jonathan Brearley, the watchdog's chief executive, said: "In examining the gas crisis, we have identified one of the root causes of the failures of many of those suppliers who exited the market is related to the way that they have managed the money paid to them by customers. This is money that is intended to pay for energy, or collected to support the wider development of renewable energy.

"However, some suppliers have been using these balances to prop up their finances, enabling them to follow more risky business models with reduced financial resilience and higher likelihood of failure. If that supplier becomes insolvent, the cost of replacing those balances has to be picked up by other suppliers and ultimately all energy consumers."

Next week, the business select committee will question some of the UK's biggest suppliers over their handling of the energy crisis. Concerns include some firms encouraging customers to sign up to fixed-rate deals that are more expensive than the cap.

Chief executives from E.ON, EDF, Scottish Power, and British Gas owner Centrica will take part in the meeting. The bosses of Bulb and Avro will also be questioned over their management before the companies collapsed last year. Avro folded owing £90million to customers and its failure is expected to cost consumers £700million.

Meanwhile, new figures out today show energy bills will stay well above £2,000 for two more years, despite Rishi Sunak's £200 loan scheme. Cornwall Insights, which predicted the recent 54% rise in the cap on average energy bills to £1,971, said it had increased its forecasts for upcoming changes to the ceiling, which is determined by the energy regulator, Ofgem.

It warned that prices staying higher for longer would undermine Sunak’s plan to ease the pressure on household finances by giving bill payers a controversial one-off £200 discount on bills, paid back in £40 instalments over five years.

Cornwall left its prediction for the coming winter unchanged, estimating that the price cap will hit £2,607, meaning households will have seen their bills double in the space of a year. While it expects the cap to fall from that record high, it no longer expects a significant drop. The change comes after gas prices stopped dropping sharply and began to level off, with the risk now weighted towards further increases.

Craig Lowrey, the principal consultant at Cornwall Insight, said: "The exclusion of material new policies for energy efficiency in the energy security strategy were a missed opportunity. While the government has already offered some support for consumers to pay their energy bills this year, this was before forecasts began predicting further rises, and over a longer period.

"It is possible the government could take further action in the autumn, but we have no guarantees that further support will be forthcoming.

"Of course, many of the variables which drive our forecasts can change before the cap setting periods for next year, but the risk is weighted to the upwards rather than downwards pressure on the price cap right now.

"And with costs of living rising, and inflation hitting a record high in March before the cap rise of 1 April feeds through, then even the potential for these sorts of cap levels to arise in 2023 will be concerning for hard-hit households."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.