I love a good reality dating show, and lucky for me, there’s never a shortage of them to choose from, though Hulu's virgin-centric Are You My First? stands out from the pack. Elsewhere on the 2025 TV schedule, we’ve got Bachelor in Paradise in progress, 90 Day Fiancé and its spinoffs, and any number of Netflix dating series, like Perfect Match, which just might restore your faith in the genre. For now, I am completely hooked into Hulu's new series, despite seeing two big problems with it so far.
Are You My First? (available to stream now with a Hulu subscription) is hosted by former Bachelor Nation leads Kaitlyn Bristowe and Colton Underwood, who are guiding a cast composed entirely of virgins. The young singles go on dates and participate in challenges similar to what we’ve seen on other reality dating shows, but that brings me to the first — and probably biggest — issue with the series.
