This past week, I was in Israel with a group of lawyers from the US, Canada, Bulgaria, and Latvia on a trip sponsored by the nonpartisan Center for Jewish Impact. CJI's general goal is to serve as a conduit between the Israeli private sector and domestic and foreign governments, but it has also run this trip and one before it to give interested "legal elites" more insight into the post-10/7 political and military landscape in Israel. I will probably have more to say about the trip later, but for now I thought I would share what I learned from a presentation from an Israeli military lawyer.
I have heard countless times since 10/7 that Israel has bombed Gaza "indiscriminately" or as "revenge." In fact, every single target has to be approved by Israeli military lawyers, who vet the target to ensure that it meets the international law standards for proportionality.
Several things stand out about how Israel approaches this matter. First, the military lawyers don't just give general advice about proportionality and then let the commanders in the field decide how to stay within its constraints. As noted, they literally vet every target, except of course when ground forces are under direct attack and need to call in immediate air support. Even then, local commanders are obligated, if time allows, to get approval from higher-ups who have more training in international law.
