Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Newcastle Herald
Newcastle Herald
National
Jade Lazarevic

Historic house on The Hill sells for $12 million, becoming Newcastle's most expensive

51 Church Street at The Hill has reportedly sold for a record-breaking $12 million in an off-market sale. Picture supplied

A HERITAGE-listed house at The Hill has reportedly smashed the record for the highest price paid for a residential property in the Newcastle region.

The historic home, Woodlands, at 51 Church Street sold for a record-breaking $12 million in an off-market sale facilitated by Maitland-based Michael Maffey of Maffey Property Services.

The Victorian Italianate-style residence occupies an 1185 square metre block. Picture supplied

Mr Maffey could not be reached for comment, however, a post on the commercial real estate agent's social media channels confirmed the record sale.

"Maffey Property Services are proud to advise that they have facilitated a record breaking purchase off-market in Newcastle," the post read.

The house has six ornate fireplaces. Picture supplied

"This awesome property located at The Hill has just sold for $12m."

The six-bedroom, three-bathroom Victorian Italianate-style residence spans three levels and occupies a 1185 square metre block on an elevated position at The Hill.

The house has six bedrooms. Picture supplied

The result tops the previous $11.05 million record set in July 2023 following Salt Property listing agent Lyndall Allan's sale of a luxury beach house at 8 Berner Street in Merewether.

According to CoreLogic records, Woodlands was most recently listed for rent in 2017 at a cost of $1,300 per week.

Robinson Property's Ben Robinson, who previously sold Woodlands, was unaware of the recent $12 million sale but remarked it "seems like a big amount of money for that site".

Previous owners, Phil and Pam Fogg, who sold Woodlands for a record price in 2002. Picture Stefan Moore

Over the years the property's original landholding has been sold off in parts, but the building has remained and been steadily restored by a series of private owners including prominent Novocastrians Phil and Pam Fogg who paid $1.51 million for the property in 1998.

The couple undertook renovations to the home before selling up in 2002 for a record $2.25 million to medico Jas Chahl and his family.

The property has ornate ceilings throughout. Picture supplied

According to CoreLogic records, Woodlands was last sold in 2011 for $3.7 million.

The Chahl family initially planned to convert the house into a function centre in 2004, but this was abandoned after public opposition.

It was later approved to operate as a boutique bed and breakfast guest house in 2006.

The grand staircase. Picture supplied

The house has six double sized bedrooms including two master bedrooms, with ornate ceilings and six fireplaces.

There is a formal sitting room, a formal dining room and a ballroom, as well as a full size billiard room.

A viewing platform on top of the building has 360-degree views of the city.

The billiard room. Picture supplied

Woodlands was designed by James Henderson and built around 1877 for Joseph Wood, operator of the Castlemaine Brewery.

The prestige property was later turned into a convalescent hospital, Iluka, for World War I soldiers and was renamed Centaur Hospital during World War II.

A file image of Woodland from 2004. Picture Jamie Wicks

It later became a boarding house before it was a private hospital run by Dr William Bowmore for 24 years until 1979.

The median house price at The Hill is $2.14 million, according to CoreLogic.

The rise of Newcastle's prestige property market

The $12 million sale follows the recent listing of a 428-square metre beachfront apartment in Newcastle, which is also chasing an eight figure sum.

The four-bedroom, five-bathroom property at 1207/75 Shortland Esplanade listed with Anthony Di Nardo alongside Jackson Morgan at Belle Property is understood to have an asking price of around $10 million.

8 Berner Street in Merewether sold for $11.05 million in July 2023. Picture supplied

In addition to Salt Property's $11.05 million sale last year, another Merewether property at 32 John Parade once held the title at the most expensive in Newcastle after it sold for $10.25 million in May 2022.

In 2021, the landmark Barrymore house at 44 Kilgour Avenue in Merewether sold for $8.7 million.

In November, Colliers Residential selling agent Anthony Merlo oversaw the $8.5 million sale of a penthouse in the Royal apartments overlooking Newcastle Beach.

The view from the 16th floor of the penthouse apartment that sold for $8.5 million in November 2023. Picture supplied

Prior to that, another penthouse nearby at 801/1 Scott Street in Newcastle East sold with Movable for $8.3 million in an off-market sale in September 2022.

Last year, a house at 3 Berner Street in Merewether sold for an undisclosed sum understood to be in excess of $8 million with Natalie Tonks of Presence Real Estate.

- Readers can now subscribe to Australian Community Media's free weekly Newcastle Herald property newsletter.

The newsletter will keep you informed about what's currently making headlines in the region's real estate market and beyond.

To sign up, click here, scroll down, enter your details, click the 'property' box and then click 'subscribe'.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.