Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Entertainment
Nick Ahad

Great Expectations review – Bengal in 1905 is tailor-made for Dickens

Cecilia Appia, slightly smiling, faces a serious-looking Esh Alladi in Great Expectations
This milieu fits the tale perfectly … Cecilia Appia as Estella and Esh Alladi as Pipli in Great Expectations at the Royal Exchange theatre, Manchester. Photograph: Ellie Kurttz

The South African actor John Kani once told director Greg Doran he believed Julius Caesar was Shakespeare’s “African play”. So convinced was Doran that, soon after, he staged at the Royal Shakespeare Company an entirely convincing version of the play about the Roman emperor set in Africa.

You can’t help but be similarly convinced by Tanika Gupta’s argument, which she lays out against a beautiful stage design from Rosa Maggiora, that Great Expectations is, quite clearly, Charles Dickens’ Indian novel. The milieu fits the often-told tale like a lace glove.

Dickens, the great chronicler of British class, has provided a framework that Gupta exploits with depth and nuance to find deeper, unexpected resonances where the story of Pip, who here becomes Pipli, still examines class injustices but also has something to say about colonialism, Indian independence, partition and the role of the invader.

Two men in saris, arms behind their backs and one with a beard, peer through a gate with curly rails and a big lock
Outside looking in … Esh Alladi with Nav Sidhu as Panda in Great Expectations. Photograph: Ellie Kurttz

It’s a big task to grapple with so many subjects, and the story sometimes sprawls over its almost three-hour running time, but thanks to deft direction from Pooja Ghai it never drags. Gupta and Ghai previously collaborated on The Empress at the RSC – where that production sometimes skimmed across the surface of the story, here they dig into each aspect of the several tales woven together.

Much hangs on the performance of Esh Alladi as Pipli, the young boy who rescues an escaped convict and finds himself repaid many times over. Alladi does an earnest job without ever quite crossing the footlights to truly connect with the audience, while the cast around him make much of their smaller parts, particularly the always reliable Andrew French as Malik (or, as Dickens had him, Magwitch) and Catherine Russell with a surprisingly comic turn as Miss Havisham.

Gupta’s lived experience means the religious and cultural specificity of the characters is authentic in a way that adaptations of such stories are often not. The result might leave some sections of the audience who are less au fait with the cultural traditions of the characters or the partition of Bengal in 1905 scratching their heads, but if it leads to further investigation, and it probably will, then Gupta has achieved something quite impressive here.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.