Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame Case Argues He Was Even More Impactful Than Peyton

There’s a legitimate case to make that Eli Manning had a better, more impactful NFL career than his older brother, Peyton. | Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Let’s start here with an exercise, a blind taste test. In it, you are an NFL general manager. You must pick between two quarterbacks. Your legacy, not to mention your ability to remain in that job, rests on this specific decision.

The first quarterback will win NFL games at a 68% clip. He will complete passes with 64.9% accuracy, compile a touchdown percentage of 5.5 and an interception percentage of 2.7 and a QB rating of 94.9.