From Taibbi v. Higgins, decided yesterday by Judge George Daniels (S.D.N.Y.):
This action centers around Owned: How Tech Billionaires Bought the Loudest Voices on the Left ("Owned" or the "Book"), a book authored by Higgins and published by Bold Type Books. Owned purports to explore "how tech elites and formerly left-wing journalists forged an alliance" to create a "new right-wing media ecosystem."
As relevant here, the Book depicts Plaintiff as one of several independent journalists whose politics shifted in recent years to attract a more conservative audience. Plaintiff began his writing career in post-Soviet Russia. In 2004, Plaintiff joined Rolling Stone, where he gained acclaim reporting on "the big banks and the excesses of Wall Street" during the 2007–2008 financial crisis. According to the Book, Plaintiff's image among liberal pundits declined after Plaintiff pushed back on allegations of Russian electoral interference in the 2016 presidential election and "old misogynistic writings resurfaced," The Book claims that "[a]fter his rejection by the left, [Plaintiff] turned to a new right-wing audience and became increasingly beholden to their priorities." In 2020, Plaintiff left Rolling Stone for Substack, a subscription-based newsletter service.
In 2022, Elon Musk purchased the social media website Twitter (now known as X). The Book states that Musk, in an effort "to expose the rot at the core of the entire company," sought out reporters to review internal company documents. These documents would purportedly "show[ ] how Twitter had responded to requests for censorship from the government and made decisions on questionable content." Musk eventually offered Plaintiff the opportunity to review the "Twitter Files," so long as he published his reporting on the platform.
