UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has faced down rebels in his ruling Conservative party by winning a knife-edge parliamentary vote on his latest plans to send migrants to Rwanda.
Sunak, in power for just over a year, has staked his political future on cutting record levels of regular and irregular migration, and the issue is likely to feature prominently at the next election.
In a tense vote after an afternoon of debate on Tuesday, the Prime Minister saw off a Tory rebellion, winning the first substantive hearing of the so-called Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill by 313 votes to 269.
But he potentially faces making more concessions in the new year to uncompromising right-wingers, who say the bill is not tough enough.
🚨 2days vote in Parl on the emergency Rwanda Bill is a defeat for human decency & a hammer blow for the rule of law.
— Yasmine Ahmed (@YasmineAhmed001) December 12, 2023
The 🇬🇧 Gov & MPs who voted in favour have shown absolute disregard for the rule of law & int'l rules-based order.
⬇️https://t.co/mkQFlgKAqy via @newscomauHQ
Human Rights Watch UK director Yasmine Ahmed called the result "a defeat for human decency and a hammer blow for the rule of law".
MP Mark François – a thorn in the side of Theresa May's government over her Brexit proposals – said the so-called "five families" of hardline Tory factions opposed the bill as it stood.
"The prime minister has been telling colleagues today he is prepared to entertain tightening the bill," the arch Brexiteer said before the vote.
"With that aim, at the committee stage we will aim to table amendments which, we hope, if accepted, materially improves and removes some of its weaknesses," he said.
"Let's pick this up again in January."
'Temporary reprieve'
Political scientist Tim Bale, from Queen Mary University of London, said Sunak's "arm-twisting and promise-making in the end did the trick".
"But it's a temporary reprieve rather than a triumph for Rishi Sunak," he said.
"There are plenty of hurdles he still has to jump and, given the level of abstentions from Tory MPs who want to see the bill made even more draconian than it is already, there's absolutely no guarantee they'll be surmountable.
"And even if they are, this legislation still has to get through the [upper chamber House of] Lords."
Sunak called the bill "the toughest ever anti-immigration law", proposing that "the British people should decide who gets to come to this country – not criminal gangs or foreign courts".
"We will now work to make it law so that we can get flights going to Rwanda and stop the boats," he wrote on X.
The British people should decide who gets to come to this country – not criminal gangs or foreign courts.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) December 12, 2023
That’s what this Bill delivers.
We will now work to make it law so that we can get flights going to Rwanda and stop the boats.
The emergency bill, published just last week, is Sunak's answer to a unanimous Supreme Court ruling last month that deporting asylum seekers to Rwanda was illegal under international law.
Earlier, interior minister James Cleverly acknowledged that the plans were "novel" and "pushing at the edge of the envelope" but addressed the court's concerns.
He told MPs that extreme action was needed to break the business model of "evil people-smuggling gangs" preying on the vulnerable.
"This is lawful, this is fair, this is necessary ... This is how we restore confidence in our immigration and take control of our borders," he said.
High stakes
The bill is part of the UK government's wider action to cut record levels of regular and irregular immigration that is likely to be a key issue at next year's election.
But by seeking to declare Rwanda safe – despite concerns from human rights monitors – and removing legal challenges to deportation orders, Sunak has triggered deep factional Tory infighting not seen since wrangling over what form Brexit should take.
Opposing hardliners are more liberal Tories who are concerned they could see the UK break international law if the bill is amended down the line.
Sunak's authority would have been severely dented had he lost, and in a sign of the high stakes, UK climate minister Graham Stuart was recalled from the Cop28 summit in Dubai to vote.
The UK-Rwanda deportation plan was first announced by Sunak's predecessor Boris Johnson last year as a way of dealing with increasing numbers of migrants crossing the Channel from France in small boats.
Labour's interior affairs spokeswoman Yvette Cooper said £240 million had already been spent without a single migrant being sent to Rwanda, with £150 million more promised by 2026.
She called it a "gimmick" that would have minimal impact on numbers and urged the government to instead tackle the lengthy asylum backlog, which is costing some £8-million a day to UK taxpayers.
