Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The National (Scotland)
The National (Scotland)
National
Laura Webster

Anger as Alan Titchmarsh compares the Queen to Nelson Mandela

The Queen's Jubilee was celebrated by celebrity hosts including Alan Titchmarsh

TV PRESENTER Alan Titchmarsh compared the Queen to Nelson Mandela during the Platinum Jubilee celebrations broadcast on ITV on Sunday night. 

The 70-year celebrations kicked off with a star-studded equestrian extravaganza at an area near Windsor Castle, featuring Hollywood actors Tom Cruise and Dame Helen Mirren, narrator Omid Djalili as well as gardener Titchmarsh.

The event was staged by the Royal Windsor Horse Show. The Queen appeared to enjoy the show and its finale, which saw her own horses and ponies led around the open-air arena.

As Titchmarsh gave his contribution to the event, he said “our identity, heart and soul is embodied by Her Majesty the Queen”.

The writer told presenters Phillip Schofield and Julie Etchingham: “This is a remarkable year, 70 years for a remarkable woman whom I’ve met quite a lot and been bowled over by because she’s such ferociously good company.

“She has enormous quiet charisma like Nelson Mandela did, he had a kind of grace and the Queen’s the same."

He went on: “If we don’t know our own family history, we know hers and she in a way shares her lineage with us and her history is our history, and that matters to us. Whether we’re conscious of it or not.”

South African anti-apartheid revolutionary Mandela endured 27 years in prison after opposing the country's cruel system, before going on to become the first black president in the first free and fair democratic election.

Anti-monarchy campaigners Republic criticised the veteran broadcaster for his choice of comparison.

Nelson Mandela visits Glasgow, 1993

"This is where fawning just becomes offensive," Republic said. "Imagine thinking there was any comparison between the Queen and Nelson Mandela."

Activist and political commentator Dr Shola Mos-Shogbamimu also hit out at the gardening expert. She said: "Comparing the Queen to Nelson Mandela is not only obtuse but an outright insult.

"Mandela sacrificed his life & liberty for his people - oppressed by the White Supremacy [the] British Monarchy upholds.

"The Queen could not walk in Mandela’s shadow."

As journalist Kevin Macguire pointed out the comparison made during the show, which he described as a "grovel fest", some supporters of the monarchy took the opportunity to attack him.

Former Ukip leader Henry Bolton OBE told the Mirror associate editor: “Unlike you @Kevin_Maguire, Nelson Mandela had huge respect for Queen Elizabeth, and he’d be immensely uncomfortable at you using his name in your insecure, chip on the shoulder campaign to undermine our monarchy.”

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.