Reviews for the buzzy new romance series Every Year After are in — and critics have agreed that it doesn’t capture the same magic as The Summer I Turned Pretty.
Based on a 2022 novel by Canadian author Carley Fortune, the new Amazon Prime Video teen romance drama follows Persephone Fraser (Sadie Soverall), who returns home for the first time in a decade for a funeral and is faced with her first love, Sam (Matt Cornett), and his older brother, Charlie (Michael Bradway).