#1 #12 Brownie The Bear With Korean Tags ($1,399.95)
Brownie the Bear first debuted in June 1993, but the Beanie Baby was short-lived under that name. Production errors and typos led Ty to retire the plush and reissue it as Cubbie, as detailed by Beaniepedia.
More than 30 years later, the original Brownie the Bear ranks as the 12th most valuable Beanie Baby ever produced by Ty Inc., but only under very specific conditions.
Collectors primarily chase versions with the rare “Brownie” name tag, which have sold for as much as $1,399.95 on eBay.
