The factual allegations from an earlier iteration of the case:
Tallman … lives in the city of Boardman, Oregon, in Morrow County. He owns and operates a coffee shop in Boardman called, "The Farmer's Cup." … Miller … grew up in Boardman. In approximately April 2019, she began working at The Farmer's Cup, as a server. She was 16 years old. Tallman hired Miller and was her supervisor. Shortly after she began working for Tallman, Miller [alleged that she] "experienced what [she] now know[s] to be highly inappropriate behaviors from a 40-year-old man toward a 16-year-old girl." She describes that [alleged] behavior in detail in her declaration.
She adds that "Tallman would only engage in these behaviors when there wasn't another adult present" and that she "did not feel safe working with Tallman." She also witnessed a friend and co-worker experience similar behavior from Tallman. In August 2019, Miller and her friend were at sports practice. They discussed Tallman's behavior and were overheard by their coach, who was a mandatory reporter under Oregon law. The coach reported what he had heard to the Boardman Police Department. Shortly thereafter, Miller, accompanied by her parents, was interviewed by the Boardman Police, who prepared a report. No charges were ever brought against Tallman.
Tallman sued for defamation, and the district court held that, because he had been a candidate for local elected office, he was a public figure. He could thus prevail in his defamation case only if he could show "actual malice" on Miller's part, which is to say knowing or reckless falsehood.
