Hey Puff! Rabbi Neil here. I know you’re in the studio, laying down your next mega hit. A thought: people are soooo tired of hearing songs about chillin’ in the VIP room with a bottle of Kristol. Why not make that table bottle Manischewitz instead? They really have some very drinkable vintages nowadays. Or, better, a nice Dr. Brown’s cream soda. Show the home team a little love. I know that the Sanhedrin would be grateful, and you’d find a little something extra in next month’s envelope ...
Two things about bigotry that don’t get said nearly often enough:
First, it’s a kind of stupidity. A low, dank and nauseating sub-cellar of ignorance. The world just doesn’t work the way haters seem to think it does. Assuming their bile is sincere, and not just empty words that bad people throw at others, lashing out instinctively.
The kerfuffle over Kanye West — whoops, “Ye,” he changed his name and might want to consider doing so again — quickly devolved into an exercise in accounting, keeping track of how badly his antisemitic spew hurt his sprawling business empire. Which meant that not enough consideration was given to his original offending remarks, such as the suggestion that rival singer, producer and lifestyle tycoon Sean “Puffy” Combs is somehow “controlled” by the Jews, followed by Ye’s threat to go “DEATHCON 3 on JEWISH PEOPLE.”
What does that second part even mean? The funny thing — funny sad, not funny funny — is that Ye probably meant “DEFCON,” a state of military readiness, and it was just an illiterate gaffe. An unfortunate slip, since wishing death on people, particularly Jews, tends to catch attention in our mass shooting age. The worst antisemitic massacre in American history, 11 worshippers slaughtered in a synagogue in Pittsburgh, happened in 2018.
We need to notice, because our political climate, at home and globally, increasingly takes its cue from antisemitism’s embrace of utter lies, from the blood libel to the Protocols of the Elders of Zion to this, which showed up in my email inbox Monday:
“All INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES in America and Europe, now know that the disastrous [WTC 911] attack was planned and realized by the American CIA and Mossad with the help of the Zionist world, to place the blame on Arab countries and to persuade the Western powers to intervene in Iraq and Afghanistan ...”
That reasoning is the exact same logic that Alex Jones used to declare Sandy Hook was fake — you don’t like the result, in Sandy Hook’s case another stark example of the need for America to do better dealing with guns. So you pretend that result was someone’s intentional goal all along, as part of a plot. It’s like blaming ice cream for causing hot summer days.
Frankly, antisemitism is so much a part of the background noise, it’s surprising Ye got burned. In some circles, antisemitism doesn’t even register as hate. Visit any liberal college for their “Oppressed People’s Day of Action” and the groups gathered would object if kids from Hillel show up to take their place among them on the quad. Because Israel. As if any random Jewish undergraduate must answer for the policies of a Middle Eastern nation halfway around the world. And because they think “Jews aren’t oppressed; they run the world.” Maybe that was Ye’s mistake, singling out Puffy Combs. He said the silent part out loud.
Leading to the second little known truth: prejudice is universal. It is not like syphilis, a loathsome illness confined to certain sufferers and not touching the general population who are blissfully free of its negative effects, provided they shun the contaminated.
Rather, it’s like bacteria — a general condition found to some degree in all human beings, of every race, religion and ethnicity. Most have no outward signs. Some are overwhelmed and debilitated. That’s why Trump is so dangerous. He didn’t make people racists — the germs are already there, in all of us — he just said it’s OK, and millions believe him. That’s why they love him so; he gives them permission to be as bad as they wanna be.
Few are capable of a world-class self-immolation like the disgraced rap star just experienced. Self-awareness is our friend. But part of our fascination isn’t because what he said is so strange, but because it’s so familiar.
