In the world of superhero movies, casting decisions can often be highly anticipated and closely watched by fans. This is certainly the case with the upcoming role of Supergirl in James Gunn's DCU. While there were initially several actresses rumored to be in contention, it now appears that the list has narrowed down to just two strong candidates. Let's take a closer look at these talented actresses who could potentially portray the iconic character.
First up is Milly Alcock, perhaps not yet a household name but her performance in HBO's House of the Dragon certainly left an impression. Although she was eventually replaced in the series, Alcock made a significant impact during her time as the young Rhaenyra Targaryen. Her talent and striking appearance make her a compelling choice for the role of Supergirl.
On the other hand, we have Meg Donnelly, known for her leading role in Disney's musical Zombies franchise. Donnelly's previous experience includes voicing Supergirl in animated projects, showcasing her familiarity with the character. Moreover, many argue that she possesses the quintessential look of a 'classic' Supergirl, which aligns with Gunn's vision for his Superman: Legacy cast.
According to The Hollywood Reporter, both actresses have recently tested for the role in front of James Gunn and Peter Safran. If past casting rumors are any indication, the final choice will likely come from this shortlist, especially with THR reporting it. It's safe to say that the new Supergirl will play a pivotal role in the DCU, expanding on her brief appearance in The Flash movie's alternate reality, where she was portrayed by Sashe Calle.
This upcoming Supergirl will be introduced within the already sprawling Superman: Legacy film before headlining her own standalone movie, Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, based on Tom King's comics. Notably different from Superman, this iteration of Supergirl is expected to possess a more 'jaded' perspective, given her upbringing and lack of a loving family in Kansas.
Previously, actresses like Cailee Spaeny and Emilia Jones were also considered for the role, but now it seems the competition has narrowed down to Alcock and Donnelly. While personal opinions on their suitability may differ depending on familiarity with their work, it's worth mentioning that Alcock's performance in House of the Dragon was widely praised, and many predicted her rise to stardom. On the other hand, Donnelly's aesthetic alignment with the classic Supergirl image and her prior experience with the character make her a strong contender as well. Ultimately, it's hard to say who would be the better choice, as both actresses bring their own unique qualities to the table.
As we eagerly await James Gunn's final decision, it's clear that the casting of Supergirl is generating significant buzz within the superhero community. Whoever ultimately lands the role, it's certain that Supergirl will be a key figure in the DCU, contributing to its rich and expansive narrative.
