Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Newsroom.co.nz
Newsroom.co.nz
National
Bonnie Harrison

The Week in Detail: Dickason murders, KiwiSaver, and home detention

Lauren Dickason is accused of murdering her three children soon after moving from South Africa to New Zealand. Photo: Supplied

Every weekday, The Detail makes sense of the big news stories.

This week, we look at the difficulties inmates face when they leave prison, the uncertain future of the Commonwealth Games, the role of the media in reporting grisly details from the Dickason triple murder trial, the potential consequences of dipping into your KiwiSaver to pay bond, and what a sentence of home detention really looks like.

Whakarongo mai to any episodes you might have missed.

 

Setting prisoners up for failure

"They've done their time, paid for their crime and then they come out and they do another sentence. It's called a silent sentence."

Tui Ah Loo, the tumu whakarae of prisoner reintegration agency Te Pā, is talking about the difficulties people face when they're released from prison

Kohuora Auckland South Corrections Facility, a SERCO-run high-security men’s prison in Wiri, Auckland. Photo: RNZ/Sam Olley

"It is the sentence of judgment, stigma and bias."

A new report called Paying the Price says inmates not only face barriers to reintegration when they leave, but they also take big problems into prison, such as financial debts, which grow during the term of their sentence.

Sharon Brettkelly finds out more.

 

A sporting empire starts to crumble

Victoria's Commonwealth Games bombshell has thrown not just the 2026 event into doubt, but the entire future of the 'friendly games'.

General view during the closing ceremony of the XXII Commonwealth Games in Birmingham, England, 2022 Photo: PHOTOSPORT/RNZ

The Games were already struggling under the uncomfortable cloak of being an event rooted in an Empire that colonised half the world. 

Now it's become obvious that in times when money is tight, the political willingness to spend it on providing accommodation for visiting athletes, and sprucing up stadiums, is subsiding. 

"Taxpayers, ratepayers end up copping it, all for what is effectively two weeks of fun, frivolity and enjoyment of sports etcetera – which is great – but is it worth it, in that cost-benefit analysis? People are watching their pennies on every level ... it does make you realise that there's more to life than sport," says Newstalk ZB Sport's Andrew Alderson.

 

When a graphic warning is not enough

Even if you don't want to know about it, the Lauren Dickason trial is unmissable when you're scanning the websites, listening or watching the daily news.

Almost every report starts with a warning that the content could be distressing, and ends with details of helplines.

But critics say the warnings are not enough and the coverage is gratuitous, obscene and salacious.

Sharon Brettkelly talks to documentary-maker David Farrier, RNZ news boss and Media Freedom Committee chair Richard Sutherland, and Stuff reporter Jake Kenny who has been live-blogging the trial since it started.

 

KiwiSaver as a slush fund

National has announced their plan to let under-30-year-olds dip into their retirement fund to pay bond for rental properties. Should we be letting youngsters derail their own savings? 

The National Party announced a policy that would let students dip into their KiwiSaver fund to pay the bond for their rental accommodation. Photo: Lynn Grieveson

BusinessDesk's investments editor Frances Cook says no.

"It is attacking KiwiSaver at a time it will have the biggest impact. [If] you take out even just $800 from a KiwiSaver when you're young ... a conservative estimate of what that could cost you by the time you're 65 is $16,800.

"If you open up KiwiSaver for every problem, then you have no retirement savings anymore and we have a looming crisis of poverty."

But financial journalist and commentator Mary Holm says it's not so bad.

"You are missing out on the growth on that money, but it's not a big amount. This proposal is not stupid, because the money's going back into KiwiSaver ... it's not lost forever. 

Tom Kitchin hears from both sides and canvasses a group of university students about their KiwiSavers.

 

The home detention solution

The spotlight's been on home detention since the Auckland CBD shootings.

Matu Reid was serving a sentence of home detention when he fatally shot two workers at a construction site on Auckland's Queen Street. Photo: Facebook/TYLA Youth Development Trust

Questions raised from the tragedy include: why was a man with a record of violence not in jail? How did Matu Reid get home detention when his list of crimes was long and included strangling his partner?

Tom Kitchin asks if home detention is the easy option. He speaks to criminal defence lawyer John Munro, NZ Herald journalist Derek Cheng, and Auckland University associate professor of law Carrie Leonetti.

 

Long Read: The Gloriavale employment case

This is The Detail's Long Read  one in-depth story read by us every weekend.

The women were taught from birth to submit to male leadership in all aspects of their life and any suggestion of "choice" was largely illusory, Chief Judge Christina Inglis said. Photo: Nathan McKinnon/RNZ

This week, it's the Gloriavale employment case, written and read aloud here by RNZ's Jean Edwards.

The Employment Court has found that former Gloriavale women Serenity Pilgrim, Anna Courage, Rose Standtrue, Crystal Loyal, Pearl Valor and Virginia Courage were employees who worked extremely hard under punishing conditions for years on end.

You can find the full story, including photos, here.

In a case traversing challenging spiritual terrain and the Southern Alps, 50 witnesses came to tell their gospel truth before the court's chief judge. Slave labour or a labour of love?

 

Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.  

You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.