When it comes to crafting a picture-perfect Christmas, nobody does it quite like Martha Stewart. She has long been the gold standard for hosting the holidays to the absolute most, for festivities that feel both inviting and undeniably aesthetically pleasing.
So it is no surprise that after the release of the lifestyle expert's Netflix documentary 'Martha', the internet has reignited our passion for '90s Martha Stewart nostalgia, and we think it is just the inspiration we've been searching for for our Christmas decorating ideas this year.
From decadent tablescapes to her traditional deck the halls attitude, a Martha Stewart-approved Christmas is certainly far from pared-back. Here's how we're looking to recreate her vintage aesthetic and bring a little Martha magic into every corner of our homes this Christmas.
How to have a very Martha Stewart Christmas
The queen of hosting defined '80s and '90s holiday style with her signature more-is-more approach to hosting, timeless Christmas decorating ideas, and warm nostalgia. Her festive crafts and creations capture the spirit of a cozy, classic Christmas like no other.
Whether you have a back catalog of old magazine covers and Martha Stewart books to leaf through for inspiration or not, this is your guide to dive into Christmas joy the Martha Stewart way.
1. Stick to the classics
While Martha isn't afraid to experiment with new colors and styles, to channel her very classic vibe staying true to tradition is essential.
Rich greens, deep reds, and shimmering golds are staples of Stewart’s festive style, complemented by natural materials like pinecones, cedar branches, and fresh foliage garlands. The '90s were about embracing what felt authentic and comforting, especially when it came to holiday decor.
The classic Christmas color palette will always endure for good reason but to balance tradition with some contemporary style, focus on layering textures like velvet ribbons, knitted stockings, and classic plaid patterns to soften the look. And, if you’re feeling really creative, channel Stewart’s signature DIY spirit by crafting your own touches.
2. Choose vintage and nostalgic ornaments
Vintage Christmas decor, while not exactly a trend, has certainly made a comeback this year as we all look to nostalgic festive memories to help us evoke the joy of Christmases past.
Look to channel your inner Martha with some Martha Stewart-style vintage Christmas tree ornaments as shown in this throwback Christmas tree shot Martha shared on Instagram. Adorned with garlands, pinecones, and pretty carved wooden ornaments, the standout piece on her vintage tree is the '90s photo frame ornament that are back en vogue in 2024.
Whether it’s mercury glass baubles, hand-painted figurines, or heirloom pieces passed down through generations, these retro ornaments evoke the sentimental spirit of Christmas.
With an antique feel, this bow-topped picture frame ornament was designed exclusively for Pottery Barn Teen by LoveShackFancy to add a fanciful touch to your tree.
Taking a leaf out of Martha Stewart's Christmas images from the past, these vintage sugared fruit decorations are dated pre-2000s and will look oh-so Martha stacked along your mantel or centerpiece.
There's something so nostalgic about mercury glass ornaments and this set depicting the 12 days of Christmas couldn't feel any more traditional.
3. Create a Christmas spread of dreams
One of the hallmarks of a Martha Stewart-style Christmas is a stunning holiday tablescape for enjoying a long luxurious lunch or a decadent grazing table piled high with decor and delicious homemade delights.
Start with the tablecloth to set your backdrop. You can either buy something ready-made or look to DIY your own with an old bed sheet and some stencils or paint, a la Martha. Then be sure to focus on a statement centerpiece and don't forget to bring out your best china. Layer chargers, china, and glassware in complementary hues – think gold-rimmed pieces paired with deep reds or emerald greens.
In this video, Martha talks us through her love of mixing old and new to 'further enhance the table' with pieces from the thrift or consignment store to create a 'warm and inviting' tablescape. Finally, details make all the difference in elevating your spread so look to add place cards, vintage silverware, and beautiful serving dishes to add the final flourish.
In the video Martha gives each place setting their own salt & pepper pot, but we think these elegant brass Salt/Pepper Mills add an old-world charm and can be shared among all guests.
It wouldn't be a retro Christmas without a poinsettia-print here or there. This festive floral tablecloth designed with Studio McGee is made from 100% cotton for an easy clean-up.
Made in Portugal, Juliska's Christmas platter strikes a jolly winter scene to serve up your Christmas turkey or an overflowing stack of roast potatoes.
Wow your guests with a homemade bake this Christmas, made all the merrier with this Santa's Sleigh Loaf Pan that molds a festive scene onto your creation.
Each of these handmade cabbage leaf charger plates is cast in traditional molds and hand-glazed by skilled craftspeople. Layer it up with your day-to-day china for a playful addition.
These authentic vintage cheese knives curated by the team at Magnolia will certainly finesse your final course. As each piece is vintage, each set will be totally unique.
4. Hang garlands and wreaths at every turn
Nothing says Christmas quite like the lush greenery of Christmas garlands and Christmas wreaths, and no one does it better than America's favorite TV personality, Martha.
Her homes were adorned with swathes of Christmas foliage ideas at every turn, transforming everywhere from the staircase to the mantel into a festive haven. To emulate this iconic look, prioritize high-quality greenery, whether fresh or faux and embrace the art of layering to achieve that rich, full effect.
Try adding accents like pinecones, berries, or small ornaments to elevate the greenery while maintaining the nostalgic vibe. For a more personalized touch, tie ribbons in classic tartan or velvet to add a pop of color and texture to match your Christmas tree decor.
If you're looking for a faux garland that really does look real, this artificial Norfolk pine from Amazon is almost as good as the real thing. Add a string of lights and tie on some bows to dress it up.
With a mix of greenery and rich burgundy hues, this artificial wreath will brilliant up your front door. Made with faux pine, cypress needles, and eucalyptus for foliage without the fuss.
Made by Offray, whether you use this for hanging a wreath, tying bows onto a garland, or finishing presents, this tartan ribbon is a Christmas classic.
5. And don't forget the front porch
Often overlooked, be sure to set the tone for the festivities with an all-out Christmas porch decor display. Consider a festive doormat at the entry, lush greenery, and warm lighting to create an inviting yet timeless look.
Your porch should be an extension of your interior holiday decor. Start with a statement wreath on the front door adorned with fresh foliage, berries, and a velvet ribbon to nod to the Martha aesthetic.
Take your cue from Martha Stewart's Christmas front porch, and include foliage garlands laced with twinkly lights and a large real Christmas tree if you have the space. For a whimsical touch, consider incorporating vintage accents like sleds, ice skates, or a stack of wood logs arranged artfully.
Give your friends and family a festive welcome with a doormat at your door. This "Happy Holidays" coir mat features a tiny, timeless, tree-carrying truck.
Recreating the nostalgic '90s Christmas aesthetic made famous by Martha Stewart is about more than just decorations – it’s about embracing the joy, warmth, and traditions that make the holiday season truly special.
Whether it’s crafting garlands, setting a beautiful table, or adding a touch of whimsy to your front porch, these ideas will help make your Christmas a little more Martha.
