Millions of low-income earners are cobbling together multiple income streams to cope with high prices.
A Washington Post report based on January BLS data concludes that the share of employed people working multiple jobs is at a 25-year high, which it deems a dangerous economic warning sign. Many others are plugging financial gaps with side hustles and gig work, but which option provides a more reliable path to middle-class security?
Consider This: What Is a Good Side Gig Income for 2026?
Find Out: 6 Unusual Ways To Make Extra Money That Actually Work
The answer depends on several key factors outlined here.
Side Hustles vs. Side Jobs: Pros and Cons
Second jobs and side gigs both come with unique advantages and disadvantages that apply differently to people depending on their circumstances.
Side Hustles
According to Side Hustle Nation, 39% of the U.S. working population maintains a side hustle in 2026, including nearly 50% of millennials. Here are the pros and cons they need to consider.
Pros
- Greater flexibility
- No layoff threat
- Potential for scaling into a full-time career or business
- The opportunity to make a passion pay
Cons
- Potential for startup and ongoing costs
- Unpredictable income
- Substantial investment in time and energy with no guarantee of payoff
- Greater tax burden
For You: Here’s How To Use AI To Quickly Start a Side Gig, According To Codie Sanchez
Second Jobs
According to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, 5.3% of the U.S. employed population holds multiple jobs. Here are the benefits and drawbacks they must weigh.
Pros
- Greater job security
- Could lead to full-time employment
- Potential for workplace benefits
Cons
- Reduced flexibility and limited scheduling freedom
- Often the first positions to go during downturns and budget cuts
- Potentially harmful work-life balance
Which Can Generate Income Faster?
Side hustles and second jobs are often less than ideal and undertaken out of immediate necessity, which means most people seeking one or the other need money now. However, the realities of the job market could make the decision for you.
The Washington Post report found that employers added eight times fewer jobs in January than in January 2025, yet the number of people working two jobs grew by 10% in the same period.
Competition is stiff, the pickings are slim and the risk of being mired in a fruitless months-long job search is real. If you have a side hustle that can generate even some cash quickly, the best income source might be the one you can get up and running faster.
Consider the Tax Implications
Side hustles offer flexibility, control, the potential for scaling, and independence from an employer’s whims or budget. However, gig work has a very low tax-reporting threshold of just $400 in net income, which is subject to the self-employment tax.
Employees and employers split the payroll taxes that fund Social Security and Medicare, with each paying 7.65%. Contractors, freelancers and other gig workers, however, must pay the entire 15.3% alone.
More From GOBankingRates
- Mark Cuban Just Exposed a Social Security Flaw That Every Senior Needs To Watch For
- What 2026 Senior Tax Deduction Means for Social Security and Retirement Planning
- How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires -- and How You Can, Too
- 6 Safe Accounts Proven to Grow Your Money Up to 13x Faster
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: Side Hustles vs. Second Jobs: What Actually Moves the Needle in 2026 for Lower-Income Families?
