Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Record
Daily Record
Sport
Record Sport Online

Is Gio van Bronckhorst right to hand Jon McLaughlin Rangers start ahead of Allan McGregor at Hampden? Saturday Jury

Will Rangers Europa League Final exertions be a disadvantage or will the hurt drive them on to lift silverware at Hampden?

KEITH JACKSON: That’s going to be the critical question where this final is concerned. Physically, they should have enough left in the tank. But this one could come down to the strength of their emotional resolve. The fear of losing is what should be driving them on.

SCOTT BURNS: It really is hard to tell. There is no doubt the loss and manner of it would have drained Rangers' physically and mentally. The mental side will have been the biggest aspect but this Rangers team have proved they are strong on that front.

FRASER WILSON: It’s similar to 2008 when Rangers crawled over the line against Queen of the South. But they have returned from Europe recently and put in big performances and the fear of ending the season trophyless should spur Rangers on to victory.

Hearts are almost at full strength but the big question - if fit should Robbie Neilson start Rangers-bound John Souttar?

KEITH: Absolutely. Souttar is still his player as well as his most talented central defender. It’s the perfect stage for him to show why Rangers wanted him in the first place.

SCOTT: The decision is Robbie Neilson's but if he was fit then I would play him. John Souttar is 100 per cent a professional and will give everything to help Hearts lift the cup in his final game.

FRASER: Yes. Souttar next to Craig Halkett and Stephen Kingsley is a fantastic three and with Craig Gordon behind them gives Hearts the best platform to win. There is absolutely no doubt about Souttar’s professionalism.

Gio van Bronckhorst has revealed Allan McGregor won't play. Is that the right call?

KEITH: No. McLaughlin may have helped to get them here but Wednesday’s defeat was a game changer where this decision is concerned. Of all people, McGregor deserved the chance to go out as a winner.

SCOTT: It would have been harsh on Jon McLaughlin if he was to be dropped, having played in the majority of the domestic cup games. The pull of it, possibly being Allan McGregor's last game, might have come into the thinking, but van Bronckhorst wouldn’t let that cloud his judgement.

FRASER: Normally I’d say yes. McLaughlin has got them there and deserves to keep the shirt. But if this really is to be McGregor’s last season then he should have been afforded the chance to play in what would have been his first Scottish Cup Final appearance having been on the bench for all three of his previous wins.

If Hearts win then who could lay claim to having the better season? Rangers with second place in the league and Europa League runners-up or Hearts in third with the Scottish Cup tucked away?

KEITH: There’s no black and white answer to this one. It could be argued that 2003 was Celtic’s season even though Rangers won a domestic treble and the same rule applies after Rangers’ run to Seville. But if Hearts win the cup then they’ll have more than just what-could-have-beens to look back on.

SCOTT: It’s hard to compare. If Hearts win the cup and finish third in the league then it would have been a great season. It would be a disappointment for Rangers if they finished empty-handed but it would still have been an achievement making the Europa League final.

FRASER: Hearts. It would make a good season a phenomenal one and elevate Robbie Neilson onto a new level. It would also mean Rangers finish runners-up in three competitions and only add to the feeling of what if?

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.