Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Wales Online
Wales Online
National
Sam Honey & Sophie Goodall

Shopper puts supermarket milk to the taste test

It's undoubtable that milk is considered an essential grocery item, with it featuring on breakfast tables all across the UK on a daily basis.

But while milk is readily available in seemingly every shop, not all brands are of equal quality.

To find the best, KentLive reporter Sam Honey decided to test supermarket own brands of semi-skimmed milk.

Sam says: "I visited four main supermarkets to try out their dairy offering and answer the question of where to find the best milk once and for all.

"Our competitors here are Iceland, Marks and Spencer, Tesco and Aldi, in each I grabbed semi-skimmed and began comparing."

Iceland

Sam decided to pay a visit to frozen-food chain Iceland first.

He said: "While I did go looking for 2 pints in each shop as I’d argue that's the most common size bought for a weekly shop, my local Iceland only had single pints.

"Obviously this isn't going to affect the taste in any way, only the price - a quick trip to their online store however tells me that the going rate for two pints of semi-skimmed is 89p, a fair price if ever there was.

Iceland milk (Sam Honey)

"Now onto the taste, and I’ve got to say, I was pretty impressed.

"One of the main things that can go wrong with semi-skimmed is getting the balance right, don’t want things too watery or too full, and Iceland got the balance perfectly.

"A quick taste test and I really was reminded of the flavours found in the likes of Cravendale, not quite exact but definitely similar, so we’re off to a great start here."

Aldi

Next on Sam's list was a trip to budget supermarket Aldi.

He said, "In complete honesty, my experience with Aldi has been very hit and miss over the years

"Sometimes they absolutely knock it out of the park and deliver truly surprising quality at a discount price - other times I’ve been left feeling like I should have just paid that little bit extra for better quality elsewhere.

"In terms of price, there is a recurring theme here as all of these choices cost about the same, with Aldi also costing 89p.

Aldi milk (Sam Honey)

"When it came to taste though, this was a little underwhelming - this time around the milk did border more on the watery side of the things.

"It was by no means bad, but for my own personal tastes, not exactly what I was looking for.

"When looking at the price it would be hard to justify buying this over Iceland’s offering for the exact same amount of money."

Tesco

It was then time for Sam to visit one of the "big four" supermarkets, in this instance, Tesco.

He said: "No budge in price on this one either at 89p, it's down to the taste to set this one apart.

Tesco milk (Sam Honey)

"It was a definite improvement on Aldi’s, and was almost identical to Iceland’s, perfectly balancing the flavours and keeping the optimal consistency.

"Those two are now neck and neck, so it is down to our last choice of the day to see who will come out on top."

Marks and Spencer

Finally, for an even view across the board, Sam visited premium retailer M&S.

He said: "M&S almost certainly comes to mind, the supermarket giant is known for it, from both their advertising and their ability to deliver on it too.

"The trade off however, is that you will usually be paying that little bit more, and this theory rang true.

"But, not to worry, as the price mark up was literally 1p, with two pints of semi-skimmed milk costing me 90p, hardly one to break the bank.

M&S milk (Sam Honey)

"Now the question is, does the taste beat out the other two or will we be left with a tie for first place?

"Simply put, M&S blew the other two out of the water, tasting near identical to the likes of Cravendale.

"This really was a delicious glass of milk, and would be perfect for all things from cereal to tea.

"Safe to say, that 1p extra really did make all the difference."

The verdict

After conducting his research, Sam came to a conclusion.

He said: "I leave you here with the knowledge that you don’t need to pay big brand prices for high quality milk.

"M&S has absolutely got you covered on that front, and Iceland and Tesco aren’t too far behind either.

"Aldi might leave you just a little disappointed this time however, but there’s always something great around every aisle in the budget supermarket so I’m sure I’ll be back there very soon."

For more stories from where you live, visit InYourArea.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.