A pizzeria owner is serving up more than just pizza, he’s dishing out savage comebacks to people leaving bad reviews online about his eatery.
38-year-old Ali Cengiz, the owner of Sunnyside Sliced, a New York-style pizzeria in Mentone, Melbourne, went viral for his “sassy” and “brutal” responses to negative Google reviews in early January 2026.
“Deal with it, people, it’s no longer the ‘customer is always right,’” wrote one supporter of Ali’s stance.
Ali Cengiz defended his Australian pizzeria and staff members against negative online reviews with savage responses
Image credits: Sunnyside Sliced – Mentone
After living in New York City for 10 years, Ali Cengiz opened his pizzeria in Mentone to bring the iconic flavors of the Big Apple to his home country.
Reportedly, he grew up in his family’s pizzeria in Cranbourne, as his family has long been involved in the pizza industry.
When he opened his own location, his mother helped in the kitchen making home-style pasta dishes and still works there.
However, after multiple one-star reviews, Ali decided to fire back, saying the “line [was] crossed.”
Referring to his $9 giant slices and 18-inch pizzas priced between $40 and $60, one such negative review read, “Expensive … it’s a bit outrageous. The NY is quite basic in flavour and texture, nothing special about the sauce.”
Defending the price point, the owner replied, “No more pizza for you! Lifetime ban,” referencing a famous line from the sitcom Seinfeld.
The 38-year-old’s viral responses included, “No more pizza for you! Lifetime ban,” “I’ll endeavour to change absolutely nothing,” and more
Another diner, who said the pizza was “on the pricey end, but not too bad,” while adding that Cengiz’s shop had been “hyped up,” received the response, “I have considered your feedback and decided that you are sour.”
A third complaint read, “Overrated is an understatement and the service seriously needs correction. I left them with my $9 and walked away, they aren’t worth even complaining to.”
“I’ll pay you $9 for every step you take away from our store,” the 38-year-old quipped in a sarcastic reply.
When another customer claimed the pizza was “dry and chewy,” Cengiz fired back, “Thank you for your feedback. I’ll endeavour to change absolutely nothing.”
Others complained, “Good looking but just that … I got a very salty one… Service experience wasn’t the best at all.”
Ali promptly replied, “The pizza can’t have been as salty as your review.”
Some diners even criticized the staff, calling them “disappointing,” and wrote, “The servers have a lot of attitude when they asked our opinion and didn’t get the respond he expected. Would never go back.”
“The same staff member you had an issue with has received countless praise. In this particular circumstance, I side with them. So long,” Cengiz responded bluntly.
However, that particular reply did not sit well with the customer, who clapped back, “Wouldn’t recommend anyone coming here as you can’t take criticism or are willing to better yourselves or the business. I wish I could give negative stars and one star is way more than you ever deserve.”
Ali emphasized how negative and “disrespectful” reviews can impact his staff and business when customers don’t even give him “a chance to fix the issue”
Ali’s approach to handling feedback left the internet divided, with many calling out what they perceived as poor “business etiquette.”
One critic remarked, “The business owner just sounds mean rather than actually addressing any of the complaints.”
A second added, “Sometimes sassy responses to bad reviews can be funny. However these customers have legitimate concerns and the responses are disgusting.”
“It sounds like the owner has tried to counter bad reviews with satire but I don’t think they’ve stuck the landing.”
While his defenders quipped, “The sass makes me want to fly to Melbourne just for that pizza. I don’t care if it’s good or not. Good advertisement.”
Meanwhile, his defenders were quick to support him, writing, “If people have an issue they should have the respect of telling the staff/owners before leaving a bad review, so the frustration makes sense even though the responses are a bit unhinged.”
Speaking to news.com.au, Ali clarified that he is not against feedback but prefers it to be shared privately, such as via email or through a conversation with a manager.
He told the outlet, “If someone’s had a bad experience, I want to know so we can make it right. Thoughtful criticism helps us improve, and I’ll always engage with that respectfully.”
His actions sparked a heated conversation among netizens about proper “business etiquette” and the right way for diners to leave feedback
“For me, the line is crossed when a review stops being about the experience and starts becoming personal, misleading, or unfairly damaging – at that point it’s no longer constructive feedback, and I feel a responsibility to stand up for my team and the business.”
Speaking about the potential impact negative reviews can have on his staff, Cengiz added, “The impact of that can be real – especially for the younger members of our team.”
“You can be honest without being hurtful, and that’s the standard I try to hold on both sides.”
He further emphasized that “sometimes reviews feel disrespectful,” especially when customers don’t even give the business “a chance to fix the issue.”
Reflecting on his passion for pizza and Sunnyside Sliced, Ali shared, “Everyone I’ve crossed paths with has been incredibly kind. Whether I’m hauling dough into the lab at 11pm or meeting trades at 5am, I always get a few words of encouragement as the lift doors close.”
“It’s a journey worth sharing, one slice at a time.”
Despite the backlash, the pizza business appears to be thriving, with Ali set to open a second location in the Gasworks precinct of Newstead, Brisbane.
He is also planning a third location in Docklands, Melbourne, in the future.
“The sass is hysterical but this is such poor form… Never seen anything like it,” one social media user wrote
