The Irish Cultural Centre in Paris held a Festival of Ideas last week to join in celebrating the 50th anniversary of Ireland joining the European Economic Community, the EU's predecessor, on January 1, 1973. The final day’s activities consisted of panel discussions and concerts celebrating all things Irish, from the language to traditional music and cuisine.
Located in Paris’s 5th arrondissement (district), the Irish Cultural Centre (ICC) was inaugurated in 2002 on the site of a former Roman Catholic educational establishment for Irish students that includes a small chapel. The names of the different dioceses across Ireland can also be seen when wandering through the open courtyard, which had rows of chairs set up in front of a stage for Saturday’s events.
The Irish Cultural Centre in Paris held its “inaugural” Festival of Ideas from June 15-17 to celebrate Ireland’s relationship with the European Union (EU) and to “enable our public to engage with contemporary Ireland and to discover current preoccupations, such as the renaissance of the Irish language”, said Nora Hickey M’Sichili, the centre’s director.
Irish speakers on the rise
The Irish language featured heavily in many of the panel discussions.
The official language of Ireland along with English, Irish has undergone a long journey within the EU. When Ireland first joined the European Economic Community (EEC) in 1973, Irish was listed as a treaty language. However, it eventually gained full official and working status on January 1, 2022, putting it on par with the EU’s 23 other official languages.
“Language is political and to be an Irish speaker is political,” said Irish-language activist Aodán Mac Séafraidh, encapsulating the sentiment of many of the panellists discussing the politicisation of the language on Saturday. Each speaker clearly had their own relationship with the language and it was "interesting to hear all these varied ideas about the Irish language outside of an academic setting”, said Sean Ryan, a communications professor at ISCOM (l'Institut Supérieur de Communication et Publicité).
This festival also “reflects this wider need of people to exchange ideas and be open to ones that differ from their own”, said Ryan.
Mac Séafraidh is a member of the language and culture project Turas at the East Belfast Mission charity, located in a traditionally Protestant area of Belfast. Turas (which means journey or pilgrimage in both Irish and Scots Gaelic) is “an Irish-language project which aims to connect people from Protestant communities to their own history with the Irish language”.
Séafraidh said the Irish language was for many years associated with Irish republicanism, but it can now be used as “a vehicle for reconciliation” between the nationalist and unionist communities in Northern Ireland. Banned several times throughout Ireland’s history, the UK introduced the Identity and Language Act on May 31, 2022, officially recognising the status of the Irish language for the first time in Northern Ireland.
In recent years, the Irish language has become more widely spoken across the island. According to the latest census data from the Irish Central Statistics Office, the number of people speaking Irish increased by 6% between 2016 and 2022 to 1,873,997 (out of a population nearing 6 million). The latest census data from Northern Ireland shows that the number of people speaking Irish rose from 10.65% in 2011 to 12.45% in 2021 (of a population nearing 2 million) while the number of people who said they spoke it as their main language rose from 4,164 in 2011 to 6,000 in 2021.
The Irish language is not only experiencing a "renaissance" in Ireland but also in France. In addition to holding events and concerts, the ICC offers Irish-language courses. During a concert by Irish singer Jack L, William Howard, one of the event’s organisers, said that when he started teaching Irish at the ICC in September 2021, "it was quite easy for people to sign up to take classes. However, there are now waiting lists for all four classes. The students are mostly Irish and French, but we also get a small number from other nationalities”.
At lunchtime, in between bites of sausage and colcannon (mashed potatoes mixed with cabbage), Irish and French visitors alike had the opportunity to chat with members of An Gaeltacht-Sur-Seine, a group that meets once a month to speak Irish. The Festival of Ideas is “a nice occasion to meet new people and Irish people. It makes me proud to see French people wanting to learn about Irish culture”, said member Linda Moloney in French, respecting the group’s rule to speak only in Irish (and in French only when necessary) on Saturday.
Economic benefits
“I think it is a great idea to celebrate the 50th anniversary of Ireland joining the European Union," said An Gaeltacht-Sur-Seine member Philomena Begley. "Some people at the time were against joining the EU; they were even scared that Irish people would leave Ireland. But we have only had benefits from EU membership, from cultural to economic and being less dependent on the UK.”
This sentiment was echoed in a panel discussion after lunch by Irish journalist and broadcaster Dearbhail McDonald, who said that “joining the EU lessened our dependence on the UK and also had economic and social benefits, especially for women and girls”. For example, EU legislation led to the 1973 abolition of the Marriage Bar act, which required women to resign from their jobs once they married.
“When we joined the European Union, we were a poor country that received over €40 billion in EU funds between 1973 and 2018,” McDonald observed. Times have changed since then. Between 2018 and 2020, Ireland contributed €377 million in average net contributions. Despite being more prosperous thanks to high-tech industry and global exports, Ireland continues to receive EU support. As recently as December 12, 2022, the European Commission approved a €1.2 billion scheme to support Irish companies affected by the war in Ukraine.
The repercussions from Brexit and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, in particular, have seen Ireland grapple with its long-standing policy of neutrality now that it plays a bigger role in the EU, said McDonald. Soon after establishing itself as an independent republic in 1937, Ireland adopted a policy of neutrality when World War II began as a means of both countering the potential threat from Germany and resisting the historical imperial power of the UK.
An Irish Times poll published on Saturday revealed that 61% of voters favoured the state’s current model of military neutrality, while only 26% said they would like to see it change. On the other hand, 55% of voters supported “significantly increasing Ireland’s military capacity” to defend airspace and territorial waters, while a majority of other voters said they were in favour of seeking help from other countries for the country’s defence needs. This poll came as the Irish government prepares to hold a series of public discussions about the future of Ireland’s neutrality and defence policy next week. McDonald wrapped up the panel discussion by posing a question on Ireland's future within Europe. “What does Ireland’s future in the EU look like, given that it values its neutrality but also wants to increase defence spending and show support for Ukraine [in its war against Russia]?”
Ireland also celebrated the 25th anniversary of the Good Friday Agreement this year. The deal was signed by the British and Irish governments, and Northern Ireland’s major political parties, on April 10, 1998. It is credited with bringing an end to most of the violence associated with The Troubles, a sectarian conflict that began in the late 1960s between the overwhelmingly Protestant unionists, or loyalists, who wanted the region to remain part of the UK, and the overwhelmingly Catholic nationalists, or republicans, who wished to see Northern Ireland become part of the Republic of Ireland. The final panel on Saturday was a discussion between McDonald and Aidan Troy, a priest who received death threats in June 2001 while he was stationed in Ardoyne, Belfast, for accompanying Catholic parents and children along loyalist parts of Belfast every day for three months. He said he escorted them to school in the hopes of protecting them, as they were being harassed by loyalists living in the area. McDonald said the situation clearly demonstrated that “The Troubles didn’t end with a stroke of a pen”. The biggest lesson Troy learned from his time in Belfast was that “there are only two things you can do when you’re confronted with violence: you can either demonise your enemy or you can talk to them”.
Celebrating Irish culture
The final events of the day featured musical performances by indie-folk singer and songwriter Inni-K as well as Séamus and Caoimhe Uí Fhlatharta, a duo from Connemara (a region of County Galway in western Ireland). Both acts performed traditional Irish music using Irish instruments, including the bodhrán (a frame drum), blended with Sean-nós singing, which is generally unaccompanied and performed in the Irish language. In between songs, Seamus Uí Fhlatharta told the crowd that he loved “having the opportunity to play around with a genre [Sean-nós singing] that is generally quite rigid," adding: "This is what this festival is all about.”
Despite the events being interrupted by heavy rain more than once, which necessitated a quick change of venue, the festival’s attendees seemed happy at having spent the day listening to different panels and musicians, immersing themselves in Irish culture and meeting members of the Irish community.
“In my opinion, there hasn’t been so much excitement, creativity and joy in being Irish since the 1996 ‘L’imaginaire Irlandais’ [Irish Imagination] festival in France. The unbridled joy we’ve felt over the past three days has brought me back to my youth in Ireland,” said Patricia Killeen, one of the leaders of Le Cercle Littéraire Irlandais (Irish Literary Circle) and a freelance writer.
“I hope that the ICC will be there – with its rich cultural agenda, and lovely ambiance of welcome and inclusion – for our children, and their children’s children, for the French to explore” and remain “a cultural and community haven for Irish people living in Paris”, Killeen said.
