A think-tank has warned many people on benefits will be financially worse off until 2025 due to a failure in payments keeping up with inflation. The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said the annual uprating of benefits in April will “merely take them back to around the real level they were at a year earlier”.
The organisation said hundreds of thousands of people could be better off if they earned less due to the way the UK Government’s cost of living payments will work, adding that more money is being spent overall than if benefits had been raised in line with inflation.
The IFS said real benefit rates were 7.6% lower in 2022 compared with their pre-pandemic levels in 2019, and will be 6.2% lower in 2023 and 2.0% lower in 2024.
In a report released on Wednesday, it said: “Astonishingly, it is not until April 2025 that benefit rates are set to recover the ground they lost over the autumn and winter of 2021 due to lags in uprating them with inflation.”
The lowest-income households are almost three times as exposed to energy costs as the highest-income households, the institute said.
Report author Sam Ray-Chaudhuri described the cost of living payments as a “crude patch” which is “no substitute” for fixing the problem at source.
Such payments, despite trying to “plug the gap” will “actually result in the government spending around £2 billion more on recipients of means-tested or disability benefits” in the next financial year than it would have had to if it had raised ordinary benefits in line with current inflation, the IFS said.
While childless families with no-one in paid work and on Universal Credit “tend to do especially well out of the crude, flat-rate arrangement”, almost half of all families with three or more children on means-tested benefits would have been better off if the UK Government had not introduced cost of living payments, the think tank said.
It suggested that instead the UK Government needed to ensure normal benefits kept pace with inflation. They described the cost of living payments as “crudely targeted” and warned they will “create ‘cliff edges’ in the system”.
The report stated: “Receipt of each of the three £300 instalments of the payment will be contingent on having been a Universal Credit recipient in a specific prior month.
“We estimate that, as a result, in each of the three relevant months there will be around 825,000 people who earn slightly more than is consistent with Universal Credit eligibility and who, as a result of missing out on the cost of living payment, end up with less income than other similar people who earn less.
“Equivalently, they could increase their own income were their earnings to be slightly lower.”
IFS research economist Mr Ray-Chaudhuri said: “Income from the state is typically price-indexed, or better. One might, therefore, have thought that those who get income from the state would be much more comprehensively protected from the spike in inflation than other groups.
“But that would be to oversimplify considerably, because benefits are increased in line with out-of-date inflation measures.
“The introduction of Universal Credit offered an opportunity to rectify this administrative anachronism, but it has not been taken.
“It was clear as soon as inflation surged in Autumn 2021 that deficiencies in benefit uprating procedures, if not remedied, were going to cause problems for claimants and policy headaches for government.
“It is high time that the Government got ahead of this entirely foreseeable problem, and brought its way of price-indexing benefits into the 21st century.
“The crude patch that it will apply over the problem in the next financial year, in the form of cost of living grants, is no substitute for fixing it at source. And under current inflation expectations, benefits will still not have entirely regained their real value until April 2025.”
A Department for Work and Pensions spokesperson said: “This year we are increasing benefits and the state pension in line with September’s inflation rate of 10.1%, but we recognise the pressures of the rising cost of living, which is why we also delivered £1,200 of direct, targeted support to millions of vulnerable households last year, and will be providing a further £1,350 of support in 2023-24.”
To keep up to date with the latest benefits news, join our Money Saving Scotland Facebook page here, or subscribe to our newsletter which goes out daily, Monday to Friday - sign up here.
READ NEXT:
Check how much of the £1,350 cost of living payments you are due this year
- Specific group of people who will not receive new £301 cost of living payment due this Spring
New interactive map helps people find free warm spaces in their area just by entering postcode
DWP rule change this month for couples working 24 hours or more each week between them
New cost of living payment warning to people due money over next few months
