Only Murders in the Building fans have been following the intriguing love life of Mabel, played by Selena Gomez, as she navigates through various romantic entanglements in each season of the show. From Aaron Dominguez's character, Oscar, in season 1 to Cara Delevingne's character, Alice, in season 2, and Jesse Williams' character, Tobert, in season 3, Mabel's love interests have come and gone, leaving viewers wondering about the pattern.
In season 1, viewers witnessed the blossoming relationship between Mabel and her childhood best friend, Oscar. However, the character of Oscar did not make a return in subsequent seasons, with the show's creator, John Hoffman, explaining that they wanted to avoid a strong trauma bond developing between Mabel and Oscar.
Season 2 introduced Alice as Mabel's love interest, but their romance was short-lived despite Alice's help in solving a murder mystery. Hoffman hinted that the intention was never to explore a long-term romantic relationship between Mabel and Alice.
In season 3, Tobert entered Mabel's life, providing support as they worked together on a murder investigation. However, Tobert's character did not continue into season 4, as confirmed by Jesse Williams.
As the show transitions to a new setting in California for season 4, Mabel's romantic future remains uncertain. With a promise of new celebrity guest stars, fans can expect another fleeting love interest to catch Mabel's eye in the upcoming season.
